Do You Feel Paul Williams Has The Chance To Rise To Top 3 P4P?

If he loses, he's through for good.

 

WHy not state who he can fight and beat to move up those spots. Asking if he could...well, ANYONE could with the right fights.

 

I think if he beats Winky.....he deserves to be top 3 easily! He has already won a Welterweight championship; he has won a junior middleweight championship, now if he beats one of the best Middleweights in the world? He should be #1! #2 if Pac beats Hatton, but I don't think he does! I wouldn't give it to Hatton because he only can dominate the one division whereas PW can dominate 3!

 

:huh Top three...beating Winky? WTF?!?!

 

Not gonna happen, lol. He's gonna have to beat Winky & SSM, and hope that the a few of the current top 10 p4p fighters have bad outings.

 

Again, there are plenty of fighters who could be ranked above him

And I never new people took popularity into account, that's just a recipe for dissaster....

 

Lots of ppl take popularity into consideration. I dont, its not right.
But if p4p is based only on resumes, DLH is still top 5 p4p.

 

But ****, if it was based off of popularity as well wouldn't DLH of still been in the top 5

And h2h doesn't really work either seeing as taylor beat Hopkins, Pavlik beat Taylor, and Hopkins beat Pavlik.. So who would be the best of the three head 2 head?

You can't say....which is why you go by there resume of recent or should atleast, and it'll be obvious that Hops should be ranked higher

The same can he said with Mosley, Cotto, and Plasterfist

 

I agree. But honestly, the p4p rankings do not match the definition of p4p

 

Who takes popularity into it? You said LOTS, so back it up. :deal

 

Everyone who says David Haye is top 10 p4p

 

He's not even top 5, and barely in anyone's top 10. And he's not even that popular. So who else is on these lists based on popularity?

 

He's popular on ESB. And he is in lots of ppls top 10's & 5's, these ppl are rating him as a HW ATG!

 

atsch Who gives a **** where posters rate him. Do you see Haye on any respectable P4P list outside of this board?