Do you think all scorecards should be made public?

How much detail would we have? "Hit the other guy really hard loads of times, 10-8"

 

I thought of the notes thing as well but i dunno if that's enough time for them?....while they eat and drink...****s

 

Should need to account as to why they gave certain rounds i think, some are clearly out of line and need to be looked at, Clev result was ok on the whole but the 117-112 boggled the mind.

Saying that though, if you were bent would you advertise it like that, why not go 115-113. Could just be massively incompetent.

 

Like you say Mand, its small scene. Another side of that is that the weekly calls for the banning/ suspension/ execution of Brit refs and judges might end up with there being not enough officials to work the fights in the UK.

 

:twisted::twisted:

just some quick notes that can refresh their memoray

 

Fair enough but if a ref has a bad day at work in the football gives a goal that was clearly offside people are able to review the footage over and over to scrutinise it. Why cant we say the same for a judge of a fight. End of the day its not the referees or judges that a bad decision is unfair on its the fans and the fighters.

90% of the time a score will be justifiable even if it is a few points out of the general consensus but we want to see if a round was given to fighter A that was in most peoples opinions clearly fighter B's.

 

You mad?

 

Exactly, The board need to start blooding younger officials at some point.

 

New blood is def, needed. Officiating pro and am boxing in the UK has been a case of having to "serve your time" before moving up the ranks.

Not right, but thats been the system for years and its not as bad today as it used to be.

 

http://www.bbbofc.com/

compared to....

www.thefa.com

 

The FA one is ****.

 

Must be how you start off?...
http://www.abae.co.uk/aba/index.cfm/officials-and-volunteers/become-an-abae-official/

 

:rofl

 

I guess. I used to work with Mike Jones the football ref and he was reffing all sorts of "crappy" games when he was in his late teens/ late twenties.

 

Yeah they really do have to graft way to top them lads, I've ref'd games at kids and adults level and it's a nightmare!!.

The board's website really needs to fix up and be more user friendly. Poor form all round for the board although i do feel Smith's done a great job since coming in IMO.