Do you think Mosley is still a top 10 PFP fighter.

Simpleton's way of rationalizing things!

IQ1!

 

It's actually 141!

 

You can't lose your spot due to a loss to Mayweather. You have to lose AFTER that. At worst he can slip down a few spots.

Tell Margo to come try and get his cookies back. If he looks like crap in that fight? THEN we can take his P4P ranking.

 

Funny thing is that you were dead on with your comment. When one of the best talents of this era (Mayweather) gets you (Mosley) in the ring and you (Mosley) look EXACTLY like another P4P fighter (Marquez) with a COMPLETELY opposite style (Counter Puncher vs. Boxer Puncher) it says you weren't able to fight your fight due to the guy standing in front of you NOT because you don't have skills.

Judge him by his next fight. Especially if everyone does the USADA testing again.

 

Of course not, he lost to Floyd. And anyone that has been around here for any time should know that if a fighter loses to Floyd then he cant be good, that is until he fights thier favorite fighter then they get good again. Example. Judah was **** after he lost to Floyd, but was good later when he fought Cotto. Hatton was **** after he lost to Floyd but was good when he fought Pac. Shane sucks right now, but when he signs his next fight he will be good again.

Without looking at the poll results my guess is its about a 60/40 split towards Shane not being top 10. Now I will look and see.

 

Top 10 in a shallow pool.

 

:rofl I was right on the money 62% not 38% is.

Posters here are so predictable:good

 

Top 10 WW absolutely.

 

UR MISSING THE POINT..EVERYTIME FLOYD FIGHTS SOMEONE WE GOT FANS ON HERE POSTING EXACTLY WHAT YOU JUST POSTED...:huh

AGAIN..U MAY GIVE HIM CREDIT..BUT THE MAJORITY OF THE FANS WILL SAY PACQUIAO IS "TOO SMALL"..

I HAD THIS ARGUMENT BEFORE WITH MANY HATTON FANS..THEY SAID THIS AND THAT AND FLOYD WOULD FINALLY GET THE CREDIT BLAH BLAH BLAH BLAH BLAH BLAH..IN THE END THE WEIGHT CLASS ETC..

IN THE END MANNY PACQUIAO WILL BE "TOO SMALL" FOR THE BOXING FAN WHO IS MORE THAN JUST A CASUAL FAN..

SERGIO MARTINEZ IS THE NEXT NAME BEING MENTIONED...

 

I agree. Marquez was shut out as well, but yet he still remains on the P4P list.

 

There's no other fighter in the welterweight division that could beat Mosley so one sided. I don't even think Pac could pull it off, he probably don't think he could pull it off either. That's why he ducked him tiwce.

 

I'll wait to see how he fairs in his next fight

 

I would like to see Mosley fight Berto now. If he beats Berto which is a lot younger then he is, that should be proof enough that he's not done yet. Then let him and Manny go at it to see where he stands in that fight. Manny ducked him for a reason, and I would like to see why.

 

Not really sure, but I voted yes. Prior to the Mayweather bout it was a lock, but now Floyd has cast a shadow of doubt in everyone's minds. Coupled with Shane's nerves on fight night, I'm of the thought that Floyd was just "THAT DAMN GOOD".

 

Not true. The blood testing will be the excuse.

"Manny was drained from all the blood he had to give. That's also why Mosley looked so bad when they fought." That's exactly how it will go.