Does Martinez constitute a top 10 PFP fighter in your eyes?

I think he has a good claim.

 

It would help his case a lot if the judges and ref didn't completely **** up his fight with Cintron or at least scored a draw with Williams.

But with guys like Donaire being on certain lists I don't see why Martinez can't be.

 

Most definitely, and also the fastest rise from nobody to p4p in most recent years. A few years ago martinez was a nobody even in hard core
circles. anybody notice how his style closely mimics calzaghe's. Now imagine what sergio would have done to kelly had he been 15 pounds
heavier and 2 inches taller. That's what joe and kelly would've been like.
The calz haters said joe was ducking kelly

 

Yes

 

Definitely yes.

 

Top 10-15 yea, I think so. I would have to really review it. He has a **** resume, he's got Pavlik and Cintron in the W column and PTP in the L column, and 10 years ago he lost to Tony Margarito. Those are his notable fights. Other than that nothing so much. So, he might be 10-15 range.

 

He deserves to be on there more than Donaire and Caballero.

 

For who they got in there?? ABSOLUTELY.

 

He is close, but his loss to Paul Williams might keep him out since I didnt't have Pavlik in my top 10.

 

Him and P W were in before this fight. Now they both might move up.

Keith

 

Yes , yes , yes !!!!!!

 

Yes, even with the loss to PW. (I had PW winning)

 

I was making the comparison between him and Calzaghe in the fight too , Martinez moves a lot more laterally than Calzaghe though but there styles are similar !!!! :good

 

If you had him beating Paul Williams it would be silly not to have him in there.