Does Martinez constitute a top 10 PFP fighter in your eyes?

yes for sure, the man is a world class fighter/talent.
and i had him beating pwill 115-113 and 112-116 the 3 times i watched the fight.

 

Yes.

 

Yes he has been pound for pound in my book and I had him beating cintron and williams.

 

Achievements not so much. But in terms of skill he's right up there I believe.

 

yeah the higher side of 10 thought probably 9th or so.

 

yes he should be

 

conterversial draw against cintron he really won.
close fight with the punisher that could have went either way, i thought was a draw.
and he beat pavlik, and is the current wbc me jr mw and mw champ.damn if he aint top ten then i dont know what he has to do next.

 

Definite yes. I think he beat Paul Williams with 2 weeks notice and it was at least a draw so he definitely deserves to be top 10 with who they have in there.

 

nobodys gonna wanna fight martinez.

 

Yes he deserves to be in the top 10 p4p.

 

Absolutely. great performance against two top fighters, Williams and Pav.
If Donaire is on that list why in the world wouldn't a really good fighter like Martinez be on there. Martinez top 10 p4p no question. :deal

 

Martinez beat Cintron and Williams but was cheated by both. He did not have time to even train for the Williams fight!

 

Yes

 

if the joke Donaire is in top 10 ( Not for me), Martinez too....

Top 5 for me

1.- Pac
2.-Mosley
3. Floyd
4. Martinez
5. Dirrell

 

There's really not a case to not have him in the top 10 imo. I've had him winning his last 3 and he just schooled the mw champion. Made a fool out of me as well - great win.