Does this version of Thurman beat Garcia or Porter?

People are really trying hard to discredit Thurman's performance against Pac, who I thought looked good even when he was hurt. The guy that we saw against Pac would have definitely have beaten Garcia and Porter the same way.

 

Thurman has been inactive and had elbow surgery. With that said I thought he would beat Pac and he didn't, so I can't take that away from him it was a good win. I picked Garcia to beat Thurman back then so I was never that high on him. I also picked Spence years ago to body Thurman if they ever fought.