Eddie outclasses Hill for a decision win.... then loses both the rematch and the rubber match due to his lack of dedication/focus. For all his faults, Hill always brought all he had.
I think Eddie has the talent to beat Hill but not the drive or discipline unlike Hill who is very displined and I see Hill winning.
Eddie Mustafa Muhammad is better when fighters take it to him as he has slow feet, he is a good counterpuncher who throws good combinations, he would struggle in this fight, another thing I will add is that I don't believe that Mustafa Muhammad was even a natural light heavyweight as he always look fleshy and also fought Bennie Briscoe at 160lbs early on in his career