Id say Eddie pretty comfortably. I dont think DM is kind of volume puncher that might edge out a conservative EMM..He starts slow and builds the pressure, but generally with power shots coming behind his impressive jab not Margarito type volume stuff...He looked plenty troubled by the bodyshots that Gonzalez was digging into him and Eddie was an awesome body puncher. I know that wasnt exactly a prime DM but even if he was half the fighter he was Gonzalez is about an 1/8th of the fighter a prime Eddie was. Muhummed takes it pretty wide on the cards, dropping a couple rounds late as DM comes on strong and gets a bit desperate. DM finishes the fight busted up and pissing blood though.
The Eddie Mustafa of the Marvin Johnson fight outclasses and batters Dariusz. I don't know if Eddie would stop him, though it was possible.
The Eddie M. who KO'd Lotte Mwale in 1982 at 175 pounds has a real shot here........ Funny, but for a dude who had trouble making 175, he sure had some pudge around his girth even when he actually made weight...... MR.BILL
