ESB Brit forum British Rankings

I don't want to **** on everyone's parade but it's just my thoughts on the situation. Williams didn't lose a fight last night- he lost a slugging match. I doubt he would have fought the same way and lost to that dude over 12. Harrison has been moved up the rankings as well, but for what? Granted, he was impressive, but who did he beat last night who was ranked above him?

 

Yeah, I agree Losfer but what about Macklin? why is he at 13?

 

then again i'm sure both fighters would have approached the fight differently if it hadn't been a 3 rounder.

i personally don't think prizefighter fights should affect the rankings at all.

 

i think Williams is out because he has retired?? Prizefighter should affect the rankings. I would still have Harrision below McDermott thought.

we do need to re-do the P4P rankings. lets wait until the end of october though as theres allot of big fights coming up.

 

murray still number 1, thaxton retired so out the rankings.

 

Ryan Brawley should be top 10 at lightweight.

 

thaxton has retired. kos you gotta keeo these up to date.

 

What about Macklin at 13?:huh

He should be just behind Jamie Moore.... updates Kos!:blood

 

Alot of it is spot on but I dont think Sam Webb is worthy of a top 5 spot... Not above Pryce and Facey.

I also dont think Fury should be above Audley.

Stubbs should be above Dilks

To have Matthew Ellis in a TOP 10 of any division anywhere on this planet is absurd, get him binned for an upcoming younster with 2-0 or something, The guys a disgrace to boxing.. Such a shame because he could have been totally the opposite... GET HIM OUT!!

 

name a fighter that should be 10th and we will consider it??

 

Froch is one of the top 20 greatest British Boxers for 20 years.

 

thomas mcdonugh only lost by 1 point to Sam Webb, so should be top 10 of sam webb lower.

 

Matty askin. Only 3-0 but he a young local lad whos training in a good camp. He would box fatty Ellis all over for 4 rounds.

Im sure there would be many others out there worthy of that spot but I cant think of any of the top of my head..

 

has yet to box 6x3's. you need to have done that to be in the top 10.