i know kos but i havent done just adding mine in like i said this is far too confusing in 1 thread for all the ones done already make a thread showing the definite list
paters original list.. Middleweight 1. Arthur Abraham 2. Kelly Pavlik 3. Felix Sturm 4. Tony Mundine 5. Daniel Gaele 6. Sebastian Slyvester 7. Giovanni Lorenzo 8. David Lopez 9. Roman Karmazin 10. Oral
Rob's list: ESB Champ Pavlik 1. Abraham 2. Sturm 3. Gevor 4. Wright 5. Mundine 6. Sylvester 7. Geale 8. Macklin 9. Karmizan 10. Barker Pater's list: 1. Arthur Abraham 2. Kelly Pavlik 3. Felix Sturm 4. Tony Mundine 5. Daniel Gaele 6. Sebastian Slyvester 7. Giovanni Lorenzo 8. David Lopez 9. Roman Karmazin 10. Oral Any thoughts?
Gevor needs to be added into GPat's list - maybe around at 5. Edit: Wright as well if he is fighting at the weight (I'm not sure). Other than that I don't see much wrong with it.
**** sake forgot Gevor id put him inbetween Gael and Mundine and bump Oral out the list and then thats a pretty solid list also should Abraham be above Pavlik the more i think about it the more pavlik has achieved
Miy list: ESB Champ: Vacant (we should strip for inactivity, mados are fine but it's a silly level of opposition that KP has faced in the time he's been lineal champ at 160, IMO) 1-Pavlik 2-AA 3-Sturm 4-Gevor 5-Mundine 6-Sylvester 7-Wright That a start? We'll worry about the other three in a minute.
i'd have pavlik as ESB champ for his win over taylor. i wouldn't have geale as high as 5 - if you are adding ghevor, geale could drop down below sylvester