ESB Brit forum British Rankings

Losfer no way Wright should be in it. He has been out for a year (removing him from rankings) then he fought to Williams and lost

 

looks good if we are not having a champ :good

 

I had trouble with that one. He should still be top ten but his inactivity has ****ed him over.:-(

 

rooq Pavlik is linear but i thought if a fighter didnt fight good enough opposition he got stripped and i agree with this

maybe ESB should get all the fans behind us and become a sanctioning body

 

Champ: Kelly Pavlik

1. Felix Sturm
2. Khoren Gevor
3. Paul Williams
4. Ronald Winky-Wright
5. Sebastian Sylvester
6. Anthony Mundine
7. Dmitry Pirog
8. Gennady Golovkin
9. Sebastian Zbik
10. Amin Asikainen

Kelly Pavlik simply has to be champion. He beat the undisputed lineal champ to win it, and has a better resume than anybody at this weight by far. Abraham is a super middle, permanently.

 

i think wrights inclusion is borderline. if he doesn't fight in the next few months he should definitely get dropped.

for 8 - 10, could pick from karmazin, pirog, zbik, macklin

 

we already have williams ranked at light middle. i believe we are keeping fighters ranked at the last weight they fought at

 

what has he achieved in the last 2 years to warrent inclusion

he has had 2 losses (1 not even at MW) he should definitly be dropped

he hadnt fought at MW for nearly 2 years before he fought Williams

Im a big winky fan but come on

 

So it's all on the same page. What we gonna agree on then?

 

its definitly

1. Pavlik
2. Abraham
3. Sturm

4. 5. looks like it could be Mundine with Gevor at 5 or vice versa or Wright
6. Could be Wright Gaele or Slyvester

after that its ****ed

 

also i have made a case in not to include Winky

no one has made a case to include him i think we need to have a debate on this

heres my case

Winky has fought twice in 2 years losing both (with 1 at LHW)
has fought once at MW in 2 years (losing)
This is a current ranking so past achievements should not be taken into account it should be his last few years form (he has none)

 

Which is?

 

Interesting arguement:think.

 

I hear you in normal circumstances, but this is the middleweight. This once famous division is a graveyard.

I feel like an idiot including Dan Geale above Winky-Wright, it doesn't make any sense.