**ESB British Forum ATG Brit & Irish Divisional Rankings** Light-Heavy List Now Up

Yeah it was D-MAC :good

OMG Wlad/Ibragimov horrible horrible

 

I move each fighter down a place for every WBO and Commonwealth title fight they have.....

Two places for interalphabetty and WBU fights.

It's a good job Ricky Hatton doesn't read ESB...... 16 WBU fights and 7 interalphabetty.

 

BB like it. Where abouts in the 100-150 range does Joe now stand in the Welsh ATG SuperMiddle rankings

 

Although I know it was a quick list just to get at Calzaghe, as far as I can remember, didn't Watson only have the one fight at super-middle - the ill-fated 2nd fight with Eubank?

He isn't that high, although I would personally have Woodhall above him.

Also, in these rankings, are we including current active fighters?

 

You've missed a British 168lb world champion off that list.....

 

**** off Kos I knew someone would have somthing to say about it. Can a man not have his own personal opinion on here or not ?

 

You will probably still rate Watson over Calzaghe

 

Sorry Gaz. I'm waiting to see how he does against Paul Smith before I consider him

 

No love for Murray Sutherland?

 

The old/new weight division divide is a problem here, no?

Should we accept guys like Fitzsimmons and Turpin into the SMW argument, since they fought both below and above that divide, with varying degrees of success, but did not actually fight as SMW's......even though they undoubtedly would have if the division was there to be conquered? Or should we just stick to the specific borders.

It would be alright at SMW because there is quite a depth of Brit talent there, but what about in the lower weight divsions. Couldn't Jimmy Wilde take in a good few divisions that he never actually fought in because they never actually existed in the time period he was active as a fighter?

 

168lbs:

1) Calzaghe
2) Eubank
3) Reid
4) Woodhall
5) Starie
6) Delaney

Thoughts?

 

Poor ^

 

That we havn't even got round to doing the heavyweights yet?

 

Yeah why's everyone jumping on the SM ones all of a sudden

 

Wharton just behind Woodhall and Benn above Reid :good