ESB Classic Forum All-Time Rankings by Division - P4P Survey Updated in October 2011

Yeah, he would defo be in the semis, possily the final.

 

Were is the Light Heavy Rankings now the poll is closed.

Keen to see them Rummy.

 

Same here, let's get this show on the road, the anticipation is tortorous!

 

Still nothing Teeto were is Rummy.

I just want to know the final result to see if Roy made the top ten.

He is a freak Jones Jr and i hope for the sake of every fan out there Roy makes the cut.

 

I think Rummy is on the job as we speak, might be a bit of a task counting everything up. Don't get your hopes up about Roy mate, when all's said and done, this is the Classic forum!

You never know though.

 

Joe only 10th?

 

Well I'm glad Charles is top of the light-heavyweights, thats where I had him. Archie Moore second seems right. Cant argue about Tunney or Langford though its hard to place Langford. Nice to see Greb on there though I expected him higher. Also nice to see Fitzsimmons on the list. Not bad overall although I would have liked to have seen 'Philadelphia' Jack O'Brien maybe sneak on.

 

Greb making the list of 175 all time does that mean it excludes him from 160.

 

No you can him in the top ten in more than one division, its not exclusive. Greb will be in at 175 and 160 most probably, maybe even top at 160, thats where I had him. I fully expect Robinson to be in at 160 and probably top at 147. There will be even more in the lower divisions no doubt. Vote if you havent already done so, the middleweight division is difficult though.

 

sweet have no problem with it just thought id ask.

 

collectively a pretty solid list...I dont agree with it all but its hard to squeeze so many great ones into 10

 

Lewis is overated in my opinion hes lucky to be in the top 10,i think holyfield should be in his place and lewis should be 11 or 10 at best,holyfield had seen better days when he fought lennox even at maybe 80% he nearly pulled it out in the second fight with lewis, also i think tyson deserves a top 10 no doubt hes around 7,also holmes is 3

 

Where do i vote on middleweights?