ESPN P4P ratings

Actually not too bad of a list. The top 3 is spot on.

 

better than boxing scene's

 

1a. Ward
1b. Mayweather
2. Marquez
3. Pacquiao
4. Martinez

 

1. Ward
2. Floyd
3. Nonito
4. Marquez
5. Pac
6. Martinez
7. Wlad
8. Froch
9. Rigo
10. Bradley

 

I understand you guys want to put Marquez ahead of Pac because of the last fight between them, but Pac is a better pound for pound fighter. Marquez couldn't have beaten Cotto, DLH, Margarito, etc.. Even today I think Pac has potential to beat more solid fighters at 140-147 than Marquez.

 

If Mares beats Moreno should he crack the list? Lots of good names on his resume

 

:-(

he's already on my list above Moreno because of his resume. I think Moreno will beat him though

 

spot on

 

Pac has been at the same weight class for 3 years now, though.

JMM beat him H2H, which is quite telling. It is not as though Marquez wasn't already on everyones' P4P top 10 entering their third fight.

I think you are almost certainly contradicting oneself to list Pac ahead of Marquez.

That would be like claiming Paul Williams deserved higher placement than Sergio after his loss in the 2nd fight on the grounds that Paul can still fight in 3 divisions, won their first fight, and was ranked higher than Sergio entering the fight.

 

I must disagree.

Moreno has the far, far superior resume.

 

you think so? I like Moreno, but I'm just waiting to put him up there right now, same with Rigo. Mares has a really good resume and is undefeated not to say Moreno doesn't have one.

 

No Frok?