Real Deal even at 37 gave Lewis all he could handle in the rematch having a way better performance than in the first fight. What if he was 4 years younger? I kinda feel like Holyfield's effort against Mercer is a bit underrated. Could this version of him beat this version Lewis?
I would definitely go with Evander. He fought a great fight that night. Even managed to drop the Iron-chinned Mercer. And, in my opinion, that was one of Mercer's 3 best performances. That version of Evander was considerably better than the one that fought Lewis.