The million dollar question is when was Holyfield's prime, he was faster and more explosive in the early 90's but was probably stronger and a little wiser in the late 90's when they fought. If you were a betting man you would choose the younger version of a fighter, it would have always been a close fight between the pair.
I’d say Holyfield. Lewis couldn’t find much inside which is where I think Holyfield could try and make most of the fight. It would be close but I’ll take Holyfield.