Everyone seems to be all over Arum for the fight being cancelled BUT...

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by bonds, Jan 11, 2010.


  1. bonds

    bonds Active Member Full Member

    828
    0
    Apr 1, 2006
    Im not convinced.

    This is what he and the whole Pac team would want you to believe but this is what i think happened. I stated a while ago when floyd initially requested random blood testing that the fight wouldnt take place

    http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/showthread.php?p=5751217#post5751217

    I do base my opinion on the belief that Pac is using ped's as i have thought he may be using them since the ODLH fight.

    Anyways Arum is a promotor for Pac and his job is to make the biggest fights for his boxers. Do you honestly think that he would rather make a fight with Pac fighting a guy that casual sports fans have never heard of or a boxer that has never lost? I mean what could be bigger for a promotor to make the biggest fight in boxing history (money wise) and the biggest payday for himself in the process.

    Thats why i dont buy this stuff about him not wanting this fight with floyd because of some kind of vendetta or whatever, if that was the case he wouldnt have put weeks of time and effort and stress into the negotiations he would never have even tried to negotiate or broken off things right away with the initial olympic style blood testing. The fact that pacs team countered with a blood test 30 days out proves to me that they did want the fight.

    When the blood test from 24/7 came to his attention he said "I will transmit it [word of Pacquiao's '24/7' test] to Manny once [HBO Sports president] Ross Greenburg establishes the actual date of the test in '24/7' and [the Mayweather camp] makes a proposal based on what Ross has come up with," Arum told ESPN.com from Cabo San Lucas, Mexico. "If that happens, I am sure I can convince Manny" to tighten the testing window.

    What will Manny do? I assume he will listen to me, but I can't promise anything. But I want [Mayweather's camp] to make a formal proposal that this is the outside date for the blood testing based on Manny's prior test in '24/7' and then I will move mountains."

    That doesnt sound like he doesnt want the fight or has no intentions or taking it. What I believe happened is that when it was confirmed that he took a blood test 24 days before the hatton fight he had to say ok we're willing to take a test at least 24 days out in order to not look suspicous. But when Arum talked to pac about this im sure he asked him whats the problem with you taking blood tests at some point he asked him point blank are you using any ped's? And based on what happened id say he told him that he was.

    So with 24 and 2 days as the two requests, mayweathers team compromises with a very reasonable 14 days. And now the balls in Arums court. He'd basically have three reasonable options here either
    a)Say no its 24 days or no fight
    b)Meet somewhere in the middle
    c)Take the 14 days

    Any one of those three I could expect, but for him to react to this compromise immediately, get all defensive and say i cant deal with these guys they are unreasonable we are going to Clottey its almost signed shows me he wanted out in a hurry. Why did he want out so fast? The longer he stays so close to a deal the more pressure would be to get it done. And he was probably worried that Mayweather might give in and actually agree to the 24 day window. And what if the fight goes through and Pac tests positive even at 24 days out. That would be ultimate disaster for Arum, the fight would be cancelled. The fact he said that Pac has no idea of the 14 day compromise really seals it for me. I dont believe Pac didnt know about this offer any more than i dont believe he doesnt know whats in the supplements he takes. Pac may have told him get me out of this fight but say i dont know about the compromise or Arum just decided to say it himself because he uses himself as the scapegoat and Pac doesnt appear to be the one avoiding the tests and the fight. Either Pac told him he doesnt want the fight with any type of random blood test or Arum is worried about Pac testing positive and ruining the fight.

    When start a big job the hardest part is always beginning it. When its 95% done the easiest thing to do is just finish it. You dont drop it and walk away from it. The fact that it was SO close to being sealed and the immediate signing of Clottey after the reasonable compromise is a bit too fishy for me.

    So now after it is all said and done and judging by the reaction of the board they got out of the fight without the reasonable 14 day demand being left on the table for very long and without Pac even knowing about the 14 day window. Arum got infuriated dealing with FMJ and the outrageous request of a 14 day window was the last straw. We all know Pac would have no problem agreeing to the test 14 days out he just didnt know about it right? wink wink
     
  2. VanillaKilla

    VanillaKilla Boxing Addict Full Member

    5,611
    1
    Oct 31, 2008
    Ofcourse Arum wants the fight. He knows how much $$$ is in it. He can probobly retire after that ****. The problem is, our best fighters are acting like some kind of spoiled hollywood stars :huh
     
  3. Cocteau

    Cocteau Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,506
    0
    May 1, 2009
    couple of flawed logics you got there. Too many to mention.

    But basically, you're overthinking it, it's not that deep of a conspiracy. Fact is, very simple the PRIDE get in the way. Old wounds (old feud) opened up between GBP/Mayweather vs. Arum.
     
  4. Rooney

    Rooney Boxing Junkie banned

    7,654
    0
    Jul 31, 2009
    I agree with most of your post.

    But in actual fact pac did receive the 14 day offer, and he flat out refused. Why did he refuse, well that is the 40 million dollar question?
    :deal
     
  5. Hermit

    Hermit Loyal Member banned

    44,341
    3
    Jan 29, 2008
    I have asked for a link on this before. Most reputable sites I have read say it was made AFTER meditation. If you have a link stating otherwise, I'd love to see it. Really. Not trolling here. Mediation was on one, and only one, point yet most of the reputable sources I have seen state that 21 days was offered and NO counter proposal came by mediations end. Again, seriously, if you have a reputable link, I'd like to see it.
     
  6. bonds

    bonds Active Member Full Member

    828
    0
    Apr 1, 2006
    And I would argue that you're underthinking it. Im not saying its a consipiracy Im saying that Arum quickly jumped on the Clottey fight when they were almost at an agreement to avoid the blood test.
    Hard to argue that he had too much pride to say "We're sticking with 24 day window take it or leave it you have 1 day to accept". I think his pride and reputation is taking more of a hit from walking away from a reasonable offer. But he did it to protect his best (and $$ making) fighter.

    Dont tell me after weeks of negotiating his feud decided to open up as soon as a very reasonable compromise was offered with his biggest payday ever on the verge of being signed.
     
  7. REEVO

    REEVO Boxing Addict Full Member

    7,142
    2
    Mar 16, 2009
    I agree with some of your post but i see alot of Mayweathers interviews and he didnt seem like he was well up for the fight at all, I really think Mayweather would get beaten by Pac, and funny enough i read a article by Frank Warren about this fight and he too thinks Mayweather has ducked this one As well as a large proportion of the boxing world.
    Who gave Mayweather any god given rights to make the rules up...
     
  8. bonds

    bonds Active Member Full Member

    828
    0
    Apr 1, 2006
    Im not sure if he did, Arum claimed he didnt, but the smart thing Arum did with his "immediate" signing with Clottey is that nobody seems to care or wonder what Pacs reaction WOULD HAVE been to the 14 day offer. Obviously I believe he knew about it and wouldnt have taken it. We havent heard 1 word or comment from Pac himself on this and i guess this is what they wanted as it takes the pressure off him, doesnt make him look like hes avoiding the test and makes it a mute point since negotiations are now closed and we all have to focus on Pac vs Clottey.
     
  9. timmyjames

    timmyjames PTurd curb stomper Full Member

    12,816
    1
    Nov 14, 2009
    I go this from another poster somewhere, but it shows all the backpedaling and inconsistencies in the Pac camp over ths whole fiasco:


    December 11:

    Freddie Roach: I have no problem with the testing whatsoever. They can do whatever (Keyword: Whatever) kind of drug testing that they want.

    December 22:

    Early today Richard Schaefer, CEO of Golden Boy Promotions, was contacted by Top Rank President Todd duBoef, who informed Schaefer that Pacquiao would not agree to have his blood taken within 30-days of the bout based on the fighter’s superstition of testing so close to a fight.

    Richard Schaefer: Todd told me that Pacquiao has difficulty with taking blood and doesn’t want to do it so close to the fight. He, Pacquiao, would only agree to have blood drawn before the kick-off press conference and after the fight.

    In that same day,

    Freddie Roach: A urine test is just as qualified as a blood test. [Human growth hormone] is not detected by blood or urine.”

    How is HGH test done?

    More than one blood sample must be taken on different days, due to rapid changing levels of growth hormone. A test measuring IGF-1 levels may be taken in conjunction, as its levels change much slower. Before blood is drawn, the administering health professional should be informed of any disorders or medication being taken which can lead to bleeding at the site of the puncture.

    December 23:

    Bob Arum: Manny says that taking blood from him really weakens him. And he doesn't want to do it when he's in training, but he'll do it prior to going into training, and after the fight. Every major doctor will tell you that blood testing shows absolutely nothing.

    Freddie Roach: For the record, Pacquiao (Remember, he said Pacquiao) is willing to have his blood drawn before he starts training and after the fight to be tested for steroids and performance enhancing drugs. It’s not like Pacquiao is saying no to drugs.


    December 24:

    Arum: This kid has a phobia for getting his blood drawn.

    December 25:

    Manny Pacquiao plans to sue Floyd Mayweather, the American's father and Golden Boy Promotions in the next few days following a row over doping procedures, the Filipino world champion said in a statement on Friday.

    NYDailyNews. Tim Smith,

    This isn't some issue that just came about. It has been a part of the contract negotiations for weeks. According to a source familiar with the talks, Pacquiao's representatives asked what penalties Pacquiao would face if he tested dirty, and also if a dirty test result could be kept secret so that the integrity of the fight wouldn't be ruined in the public eye.


    December 26:

    Manny Pacquiao: I have offered to give a blood sample the day of the announcement of the fight at the Press Release. I have offered to give a blood sample 30 days before the fight. I am willing to give blood immediately after the fight is over inside my dressing room. I am also willing to give urine tests at anytime any where everyday leading up to the fight. The truth is taking blood out of my body does not seem natural to me and mentally I feel it will weaken me if blood is taken from me just days before the fight.

    December 28

    Manny Pacquiao: I do not have anything to prove (to them) and hopefully, they would not succeed in destroying my image and the sport of boxing in the way they want it done. They want to dictate and step on the authority of the organizations including the Nevada State Athletic Commission. I am not guilty and I don’t have to prove anything because I have passed all tests in all my previous fights. I will all just see you in court.

    December 30:

    David Tyler interviews Freddie Roach.

    Freddie Roach: HGH cannot be detected by blood, saliva, or urine. The doctors I've talked to said that HGH and any growth harmone cannot be detected by any test.

    David Tyler: Fred, I have a graduate's degree in Biochemistry and 30 years experience in developing blood chemistry tests.....I'll leave it alone, let's move foward.

    Freddie Roach: No wait, you can't tell me that there is a test that can detect HGH or growth harmones.

    David Tyler: Fred, I'm not here to make you mad.

    Freddie Roach: I'm not mad, I'm telling you that you are wrong if you think there is a test for HGH.

    David Tyler: Ok Fred, so you are saying that HGH cannot be detected by a blood test?

    Freddie Roach: Absolutely, 100%, NO! Saliva, blood, or urine.




    Mayweather agreed to cut off testing 14 days before the fight and to have it administered by the Nevada Athletic Commission.

    Bruce Binkow, the chief marketing officer of Golden Boy Promotions, on Dec. 30 offered a 14-day cutoff as a compromise via instant message to Top Rank president Todd duBoef, who replied on Dec. 31 that “14 is no good.”

    Schaefer said he believes the fight can be salvaged over the weekend and the first step is making certain that Pacquiao is aware of Mayweather’s 14-day offer. “There are reports [on the Internet] that Manny is not aware of this and we want to make certain that he knows what Floyd has agreed to do,” Schaefer said.

    However, Koncz said he was informed of the offer by promoter Bob Arum and that he brought it directly to Pacquiao, who would not even consider it. Koncz said Pacquiao was very firm in his decision.

    “Bob called and told us about the 14 days and I brought that to Manny and he said, ‘I told you, we’re not agreeing to that,’ and that was pretty much it,” Koncz said.

    Schaefer called Mayweather’s offer “a very fair, very reasonable compromise solution” and said Mayweather is still eager to fight Pacquiao on March 13. Both Schaefer and Mayweather Promotions CEO Leonard Ellerbe have denied speaking to any potential other opponents, though Mayweather has been linked through numerous published reports with Paulie Malignaggi.

    “We’ve focused solely on getting a fight done with Manny Pacquiao and that’s it,” Ellerbe said.

    “Manny would be willing to fight Mayweather, but the tenor of negotiations would be a lot different in the future,” Koncz said. “Manny was very accommodating before, because he wanted to get this fight done and to satisfy the fans, who wanted it very much. Billing is important to Manny, but he gave that up to accommodate Mayweather’s ego because [Manny] wants to go out as the best fighter there ever was and, clearly, Mayweather is one of the best.

    “But given what happened, Manny won’t make those concessions if they come back to us.”

    Dr. Don H. Catlin, the head of the Los Angeles-based non-profit Anti-Doping Research, Inc., said a 24-day cutoff for blood testing is not sufficient to prevent abuse. One of the concerns with such a long blood-testing cutoff prior to the date of competition would be the potential use of Erythropoietin, or EPO.

    But Catlin said that wouldn’t be the only concern if there were a 24-day cutoff imposed.

    “If you have a 24-day window that’s free, with no testing, you can take whatever you want and you’re not going to get caught, end of story,” Catlin said. “[Urine testing] does matter, yes, but they’re not going to catch everything by urine testing alone. What you would do is to take Mircera [a type of EPO], which is available and which is not easy to detect in urine and away you go. You need a blood test.”

    The Mayweather fight is the fight the world wants to see,” Roach said. “It’s going to be the biggest pay-per-view fight of all time. But I think we will fight one fight before that.”

    Roach said that Pacquiao’s schedule will be constructed around his political ambitions and the elections in the Philippines on May 10. “But there is a March date for him to fight,” Roach said. “People think I am crazy but I want him to win his eighth title against Yuri Foreman at 154lb. That’s my idea — then fight Mayweather in September. And then retire.”

    The way Roach sees it, there will be no further blemishes on Pacquiao’s record by the time he greets retirement, although he does concede that Mayweather will be “the hardest fight of his life”.


    “Mayweather’s a very difficult fight for Manny,” he said. “It won’t be physically the hardest, but it will be the hardest fight of his life style-wise. Mayweather is talented and he’s good at defence. I have a very good game plan for him, but I’m sure a lot of other guys thought that along the way.

    “We’ll have a ten-week training camp. We have to work on a lot of new moves, we have to improve in certain areas to win that fight.” And would he expect his man to win? “Oh yes. Without a doubt.”


    "If they give me a 5-day window or something like that I have no problem with it," Roach said. "When they've drawn blood from Manny in the past he feels weaker for three or four days. It may be mental, but it's there."
     
  10. bonds

    bonds Active Member Full Member

    828
    0
    Apr 1, 2006
    This quote is giving even more credence now that when i observed something that made me believe Pac was using hgh from at least the DLH fight. Why would a trainer know with such conviction that hgh cant be detected. Why would Roach talk to doctors specfically in regards to whether hgh could be detected by any test? Why would he even care if Pac wasnt taking it? The fact that he has even asked multiple doctors this is fishy. Things that make you go hmmmm.....
     
  11. Rooney

    Rooney Boxing Junkie banned

    7,654
    0
    Jul 31, 2009
    here is arum admitting to his lie.

    Arum does not deny that Richie Rich Schaefer of Golden Boy, the appointed Mayweather rep along with close to the best adviser Al Haymon, did end up with a two weeks out preflight test demand.

    “It’s true, it’s true,” Arum said. “But they knew full well that we would not go for that. I think the real mistake was mine in not saying, “Sign the bout contract, then take your test requirements to the athletic commission.’ I should have said that and, if he signed the contract, I could’ve said go the commission and don’t bother me with this bullspit.”

    And here is arum saying pac refused it.

    Schaefer told SI.com on Friday that he believed Pacquiao was never told of the 14 day offer. He referred to an Internet report where Pacquiao and his representatives denied that Mayweather had offered to reduce the testing window to 14 days before the fight. Schaefer said he had text messages between Golden Boy's Chief Marketing Officer Bruce Binkow and Top Rank President Todd DuBoef during this week's mediation discussing the 14-day window.
    Arum, however, says Pacquiao has known about the 14 days since Jan. 1 and said he had an email exchange between DuBoef and Pacquiao's advisor, Michael Koncz, that prove that Pacquiao had received the offer and rejected it.
    "That offer was rejected a long time ago," said Arum. "It was off the table. They are just trying to get under Manny's skin. It serves no purpose than to aggravate Manny Pacquiao."

    I cant post the links because last time i got banned. But it easy to research.


    There you go:bbb
     
  12. bonds

    bonds Active Member Full Member

    828
    0
    Apr 1, 2006
    Interesting. Still not 1 word from Pac himself on a reason for not accepting this offer and nobody cares at this point. Its been swept under the rug with the immediate agreement to fight Clottey.
     
  13. PH|LLA

    PH|LLA VIP Member Full Member

    79,438
    2,646
    Feb 1, 2007
    I went through all that I didn't see too many inconsistencies.

    Roach and Pacquiao are two different people. What Roach accepts and what Pac is willing to accept are two different things.

    Basically what I saw is Pac compromised several times:

    - Pac proposed to have blood taken before the press conference and after the fight

    - Pac then agreed to have blood taken up to 30 days away from the fight

    - Pac then agreed to have blood taken up to 24 days away from the fight.

    - Pac never said he was afraid of needles as many people have claimed, but he obviously feels drawing blood will weaken him during his training camp and possibly the fight if its too close.
     
  14. bonds

    bonds Active Member Full Member

    828
    0
    Apr 1, 2006
    what did Pac say about the offer of the 14 day window?
     
  15. PH|LLA

    PH|LLA VIP Member Full Member

    79,438
    2,646
    Feb 1, 2007
    he proposed 24 days instead.

    From what I understand that 14 day window was set up because they said that Pacquiao took blood against Hatton 14 days before the fight. It turned out that was actually 24 days and not 14. Which is why the final offer was 24.