F.Mayweather will be a top 10 ATG once he retires with a perfect 50-0 record

He won't retire at 50-0 and he never fought the best on the way there.

 

id favour khn more in 2010/11

 

Not happening. Besides, pac will retire and will rank higher than floyd even with his undefeated record.

 

**** legacy, and now **** ppv.

sad day for the *****s.

 

With a grimace I could see someone placing him in the top 30, but top 10?

It's rather easy to reel off ten fighter's whose legacy is a couple of marathons in front of Mayweather's.

Even if he schooled Golovkin, he doesn't get in.

 

Thurman? THurman does nothing for him. Beat up Pac and Cotto though and you have a case.

 

Unless one of those 50 comes against Wlad, no.

 

:hi:Hi Gennady...:hi:bye Gennady

 

I place him in the 40's right now. The sport is rich with history of truly great fighters who fought the best of their era's in really tough era's. People forget or just dont know that. The rest are just plain ignorant.
Skill wise Floyd is second tier. Probably top 30.

 

Top 15 maybe of all time.....not sure about the top 10 bro
:smoke

 

flopjr will forever be known as the runner up to fotd who ducked the best fighter of his generation, the fotd and 8div champ.


and new................................:rofl

 

If Pacqioua is FIRST on that list.....and he does as you suggest and WIN those 3 fight......

I'd call him top 10 ATG WW.:think

 

A guy makes a career fighting once, maybe twice a year against second-tier guys and this clown MVC wants to call him a top 10 ATG?

atsch

 

the more you learn about past great fighters, the further floyd drops in the atg list. i dont have a list but im pretty sure i can come up with more than 30 fighters i would favor over floyd h2h... and i can come up with many more than that with greater accomplishments. what hurts floyd the most is his lack of great fighters on his resume, who were at the top of their game.
theoretically, in todays boxing era, a fighter can become unified champion in 5 different divisions, while fighting only the 4th best fighters in each division. so beating a "champion", may no longer mean that you can even beat the top 3 of the division.
before the 70s there were less than half the divisions of today so weight jumping 3 division was like jumping 6 divisions today.
when you start to factor all this into what a fighter has actually done, you start to see how meaningless some of these stats and trinkets really are in comparison.

 

Not top ten........ I hae FLoyd top 25-30.. and he will probably stay there. If he beat GGG or Ward, then yeah top ten...... Pacman would only put him top 20 or 15 at best........ just my opinion..... to be top ten is not easy man.....