F*&# Ring....here are the REAL p4p top 10

I still have no idea how Paul Williams, not only 12 months ago schooled by a fighter he should've knocked out in 3, not 13 rounds, would be on any P4P list. Close Margarito win 2 years ago, ok. But it took 2 fights to beat Quintana and he lost most rounds, then and beat Kolle (who?) and Phillips (who) since then. How the **** does that qualify for the P4P list? He doesn't even hold a legitimate title. Max Kellerman and The Ring was on Williams nuts lately, but I just can't believe how people jump on this one. No offense, it's your list. But where's Rafael Marquez?

 

I thought the same about Marquez. How can you have Vasquez at 5 but not R.Marquez, did you see their third fight?

 

Not a bad list.

I have P-Will a little further down.

Where is Rafa Marquez?

 

good list but williams should be just entering at 10, 9 pushing it

 

P. Williams does not deserve a ranking that high

 

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Juan Manuel Marquez
3. Bernard Hopkins
4. Israel Vazquez
5. Shane Mosley
6. Rafael Marquez
7. Miguel Cotto
8. Paul Williams
9. Ivan Calderon
10. Ricky Hatton
11. Juan Manuel Lopez
12. Vic Darchinyan
13. Chad Dawson
14. Kelly Pavlik
15. Nonito Donaire
16. Nate Campbell
17. Celestino Caballero
18. Vitalai Klitschko
19. Wladimir Klitschko
20. Jermain Taylor

 

deceant explanation :smooch

 

how do you define p4p?

as for me, 50% accomplishment(past), 50% how would he look if he fights today(future fights)...

that's why i had lopez pretty high. PW is high also bec you must forget his loss to quintana for he redeemed himself by beating quintana..i can't rank darchinyan bec he is still has to redeem his loss to donaire. Look, if Darch and Donaire had a rematch @ 115, i bet the betting would be close and wont be surprise if donaire would be the favorite.

 

Because anyone who knows boxing can see Williams is a beast. He can fight from 147-160 that's what P4P is all about. A green Williams beat a loaded gloves Margo at his own game. He's getting better and no one at 147 will fight him. If anything he's underrated.:deal

 

What has Marquez done lose two in a row to Vasquez? He should be dropped he hasn't won a fight in over a year.:deal

 

Where is Kessler?

 

1. Manny Pacquiao
Keeps on winning after the split decision against Marquez despite moving up in weight, time and time again.

2. Juan Manuel Marquez
I felt he beat Pacquiao twice, and moving up to stop the never knocked out Casamayor is a big achievement.

3. Bernard Hopkins
His shutout over Kelly Pavlik was astonishing considering his age.

4. Israel Vasquez
Two back to back wins over a nother great 122lb fighter in Rafael Marquez.

5. Ivan Calderon
Undefeated, has to move up just to get competitive bouts.

6. Shane Mosley
Destroyed Antonio Margarito, and looked great doing it.

7. Vic Darchinyan
Destroyed Mijares and Arce, two of the best fighters in their respective weight divisions.

8. Rafael Marquez
Was competitive with Izzy in both of their epic bouts, beating him in their first fight. Will have to do something noteworthy to stay on the list soon.

9. Miguel Cotto
Was not disgraced by the Margarito fight, and his ability is enough to keep him on the list.

10. Paul Williams
The guy blew out his only loss in devatsating fashion in the rematch, is moving up and stopping Middleweights. He has to be on the list.

 

21...john at 22...diaz at 23