Tito and Oscar both looked like good but not great fighters in that bout. massively hyped fight by a boxing media cheesily trying to tell us these two were on the level of any of the great Welters, and ultimately a huge let down. Tito was at his best early at Welter imo, when he had a more rounded Arguello'esque approach rather than plodding forward in straight lines and loading up on hooks and straight rights, which is basically what his style fell into by the time he moved up.Still a dangerous pure puncher that threw really nice punches, but with no depth anymore to his style. The Tito that calmly broke down Carr after getting dropped earlywas a sharper, more dangerous fighter than the one that failed to take out a badly hurt Vargas early and actually let him back into the fight(which could have cost him had Vargas been a more talented fighter than he was) for a while and needed some low blows to take the heat off.Or the one that lost the first half of the fight against the decent but flawed Reid. I don't hold the Wright fight against him TOO much, as though it was a pathetic, clueless performance, he had come out of a long retirement and only fought once against the tailor made, overrated Mayorga.
A couple of the early rounds were feeling out rounds that could have gone either way. Couple of years since I last scored it but it was something like the last 4 and an early 2. I just don't see it as a huge robbery and I don't think Tito looks to be the lesser man.
I agree that it wasn't a huge robbery but I'd still say it was a bad decision. I think it was pretty clear De La Hoya won on a rounds basis. But overall the fight was pretty even if you know what I mean. I feel neither guy put forth a great performance. De La Hoya boxed perfectly at points but coasted way too much especially late costing him the fight. Trinidad never really seemed to find his range till late some of this can be attributed to De La Hoya boxing beautifully. I really feel these two could've had a much better fight just on that given night it didn't pan out. I consider them both great, each had their ups and downs but overall they both beat a lot of good fighters in impressive fashion.
Heizenberg, nice post. Do you think the DLH fight hurts Tito's legacy at all? Despite enormous hype, that was such a disappointing fight. Tito seemed to get thoroughly outboxed for the early-middle parts of the fight, never really hurting DLH with his patented power shots.