Fight of the Fortnight #1: Southpaw Standoffs.

Frank Fletcher vs Clint Jackson

Between the 5 of us, this was the consensus.
Frank - Clint
1. 10 - 9 (all of us)
2. 10 - 9 (same)
3. 9 - 10 (we all had it for Clint but Philly, who had it even)
4. 9 - 10 (we all had it for Jackson, except me, who had it for Frank)
5. 10 - 9 (all but Jel, who had it even)
6. 10 - 9 (all)
7. 10 - 9 (Rorsch & Philly had it for Jackson. Me, Jel and Rough didn't)
8. 10 - 9 (all)
9. 10 - 9 (all but me & Rough, I had it for Jackson, Rough had it even)
10. 10 - 9 (all but me and Rorsch who had it for Jackson)
11. 9 - 10 (all of us, except Jel, who had it for Frank)
12. 10 - 9 (all but Jel, who had it for Clint)

Seems like there's a few rounds that could go either way, namely 3, 7 & the final 3.
The totals we had were
@rorschach51: 115-113
Me : 117-111
@Jel, @roughdiamond & @PhillyPhan69 : 117-112

 

Well you didn't do them and it's my thread so... Yeah! And I'll have you know I'm set to get an A in maths in my GCSE. Your ego will have to take solace in that

 

Naseem Hamed vs Kevin Kelley

Consensus between the 3 of us.
Naz - Kelley
1. 8 - 10 (all)
2. 10 - 9 (Rorsch had it even)
3. 9 - 10 (all)
TOS.

Easy one to score, not much variance here. The KD fiasco of the 2nd, can see it anyway tbh.
Me, @PhillyPhan69 and @Jel had it 29-27
@rorschach51 had it 30-27.

 

Happy now

 

@The Morlocks really did revolutionise this place on text to colour level

 

Rolando Naravette Vs Bazooka Limon

4 of us again (sorry for missing you @PhillyPhan69 ), I make the consensus/average as this:
Rd. Nara - Limon
1. 9 - 10 (all but Philly, who disagreed with the rest of us, he had Naravete winning)
2. 9 - 10 (all, but Jel had Nara winning
3. 10 - 9 (all)
4. 10 - 10 (Rorsch and Philly had it for Nara, Jel and I had it for Limon)
5. 10 - 9 (all)
6. 10 - 10 (see round 4)
7. 10 - 10 (see rounds 4&6)
8. 9 - 10 (all of us scored it for Limon)
9. 9 - 10 (all of us but Jel scored it for Limon, Jel had it for Naravette)
10. 10 - 9 (all of us but myself had it for Limon)
11. 10 - 9 (All of us)

Lots of twists here actually. Rounds 4,6&7 can definitely be split differently.
I had it 106-103 for Limon
@Jel had it 105-104, @PhillyPhan69 had it 107-102 and @rorschach51 had it 105-103, all in favour of Naravette.

 

Paul Williams vs Sergio Martinez

Again, just the Fab 4 of the Forum. The rounds...
Williams-Martinez
1. 9 - 10 (Unanimous)
2. 9 - 10 (again, all of us had it the same)
3. 10 - 10 (me and Jel had it for Williams, Rorsch and Philly had it for Serg)
4. 10 - 9 (all of us had it for Williams, except Philly who had it for Martinez)
5. 10 - 9 (Unanimous)
6. 10 - 9 (again, all for one, all for Williams)
7. 10 - 10 (Philly and Rorsch had it for Williams, whilst me and Jel had it for Serg)
8. 10 - 10 (like above, but with me and Jel having it for Martinez, and Philly and Rorsch having it for Williams)
9. 10 - 10 (another even, although it's me and Philly giving it to Williams this time, and Rorsch and Jel giving it to Martinez)
10. 9 - 10 (Unanimous)
11. 10 - 9 (Philly being "the lone dissenter")
12. 10 - 9 (see above)

Yeah, can see why this one's a head scratcher! Especially with rounds 3, 7, 8 & 9 among others being arguable, are split dead even. In hindsight, a draw probably would've been the correct decision.

I had it 115-113 for Williams, @PhillyPhan69, @Jel and @rorschach51 had it a 114-114 draw.