1) Marquez-Vasquez III 2) Mtagwa-Villa 3) Everything else If anyone here hasn't seen Mtagwa-Villa yet, you need to watch it. The entire thing is up on Just in. tv.
Having just seen Mtgawa-Villa on youtube, I think that it deserves serious consideration for FOTY, and might have won in a year that didn't include Vasquez-Marquez III.
Vazquez vs Marquez 3 Cotto vs Margarito Performance of the Year: Bernard over Pavlik hands down (though Calzaghe beating Roy is slightly #2)
Really, don't watch Dib-Luevano. It was putrid. The calls for that fight are sarcasm. The calls for Mtagwa-Villa are real though.