I would have to say B Hop, Though Manny has done well Manny is still in his prime, B Hop has done the impossible and this is really the end of his career.
PF is 1, Pac is 2, BHop is a very, very distant 3. Barrera, MAB and JMM have arguments to be there, but the others don't. Lennox Lewis should be in there, and he'd be a clear number four for me.
Pacman, Calzaghe and Mayweather stand out for me. I definitley think they'll be the three who are remembered in years to come. Hopkins, Mosley, Cotto...all great fighters. But these three are unique
And agreed, Lewis wouldn't be in the 90s, but he deserves to be somewhere. He's in the class of the aforementioned 3 fighters.
You might note that I stated (by omission) that Calzaghe doesn't deserve to be mentioned in the same breath as those guys.
Why ???? , for 2 questionable decisions against an over the hill Holyfield , giving a useless Tyson a beating and getting knocked out by 2 C level fighters other than that boring us all to death with jabbing for 12 rounds , oh and getting a narrow escape against Vitali then retiring just after !!!!! Get real , Lewis was massively over rated !!!!!!!