I know everybody lacks something, but who springs to mind for you here? Has there perhaps even been somebody who was not truly great, who had a fair measure of everything? thoughts?
Ricardo Lopez comes to mind. Threw every punch in the book including a left uppercut. Perfect balance. Top notch combos and did not ignore body work. Good legs. Kept those hands up high. Smarts in the ring and that's a critical attribute. Listened to his corner. Well prepared. Later on you could say his skin gave way. But guys in his division are washed up at 25 once those reflexes deteriorate a little.
Duran at lightweight was about as flawless as it gets. He had ferocity, determination, aggressiveness, speed, power, a great chin a great defense and he threw combinations pretty much non stop.
Hagler did everything very well. Punched hard, had speed, defence, chin. Complete fighter in my opinion.
I like the other 3, Casas war vs Katsidis is a little discussed classic I'd say Vitali Klitschko should be on here Michael Spinks?
Regarding Vitali, one could make a reasonable argument that he cut pretty easily, based on the Lewis fight. There were at least 3 cuts he sustained during that fight.
I would say one thing Marvin did wrong was in the beginning of fights before he really turned it on, he stood quite square and was open to body punches.