Jim Jeffries should be mentioned. When he retired, it was assumed that nobody could beat him with an axe, or if they did it woudl be a narrow points decision.
As generic at it is, Mike Tyson and George Foreman are two that instantly spring to mind Also: Vitali Klitschko Sonny Liston Oleksandr Usyk Tommy Hearns Roberto Duran Sugar Ray Robinson
Loma was my penultimate mention. I was tempted to put Rigo down as well, who I actually liked better than Loma and then they fought ... natural weight difference arguments aside, I expected much more from him. Thinking about it, prime Liston, 167 lbs Fitz, G-Man, Naseem, Wilde, Tunney, arguably Eubank, all had an aura about them.
Seen them all from early 70's onwards . If we are talking aura then it's peak TYSON by a mile. Sorry not a very original answer. Most of the other obvious ones have already been mentioned, so I'm giving a mention to Chris Eubank , who had an amazing and slightly unique aura at his peak.
Hi Buddy. Neat idea for a thread, you cite " intimidating " for me the fighter that most embodied the word was Liston, there have been some very good names already mentioned, SRR, Louis, and yes , there was an aura about them, the flash, handsome, Robinson, the quiet unassuming, Louis, both had auras, but they or anybody up to Listons demise by Ali, couldn't compare to that of Sonny's, the brooding, meaniceing Liston struck fear into his opponents, and a sense of revulsion to the general public, not helped by his early violent criminal background, his whole demeanour spoke of a man that didn't care, about his life or his reputation, get in the ring, hurt somebody, get paid, repeat. stay safe Devon, like you, and your posts, chat soon.
When your aura can arguably have an opponent well on the way to being beaten before first bell, then that is something - see Liston (vs Patterson) and Tyson (vs Spinks). I’ve read that John Henry Lewis was quite fearful at the prospect of facing Joe Louis. That’s not to impugn Lewis and I can’t vouch for that being fact anyway but it seems Louis did have a good number of opponents bricking it before first gong. At MW, Monzon had to be an intimidating prospect to be facing. Near impossible to hurt and prepared to torture you over the longer haul of necessary. A 1st round KO loss at the hands of Mike Tyson would be more merciful. Also, I would’ve been extremely fearful for my family jewels facing Andrew Golota. Charlie Zelenoff has the aura of being as mad as a cut snake - dangerous for not knowing what he might do next. Allegedly, Ali’s crazy act put Liston a bit off balance - facing conventional tough guys is one thing - engaging lunatics is another thing altogether. While auras are earned in good measure, including by irrefutably great fighters, they still allow for a perceived, illusory advantage which kinda becomes real if the opponent lets the self created intimidation take them over. When a fighter who can’t be intimidated comes along, with accompanying skills of course - the fighters previously advantaged by their auras can lose some serious ground - lending to bubbles being burst and major upsets occurring.
We need to add in John L. Sullivan. He had so much aura that people even bragged: "I shook the hand that shook the hand of John L. Sullivan!"