Fighters who's records can't be criticised..

No one. Even The GOAT SRR is not immune.

 

You can literally take apart any record and find circumstances of why the result should be diminished.
From catch weights, pre fight issues, health issues, pre prime, post prime... if you want to you can ruin any record.

Even the SRRs, SRLs, Durans, Alis etc does not matter ... no record is safe from it sadly.

 

Valero

 

You can't do it with whole records, but maybe individual wins.

 

In general..
People agree that Ali's resume is top 3 all time @HW

 

None unfortunately

 

its hard to criticize salvador sanchez's record. he was just coming up.

 

Super Joe Calzaghe

 

True, although it some cases it boils down to people acting absurd about it and wielding a vicious agenda. Of those you mentioned, I find Ali's to be the easiest to crack. Both Liston bouts are forever shrouded in mystery, and the second was an obvious fix, Patterson was post-prime, lost to Frazier at his best in FOTC, accusations of the ring ropes being loosened prior to Foreman which softened the blows for his strategy; Frazier was considered washed up before Thrilla, extremely disputed decisions to Norton (who'd previously broken Ali's jaw and beaten him) and Young, etc etc.

SRL: Benitez "didn't train", Duran was out of shape, Hearns was weightdrained, Kalule was an early stoppage and Hagler was past it. This feels a lot more ridiculous, however.

 

Miguel Cotto's record is certifiable and can't be criticized.

Wladimir Klitschko has fought and beat the best available opposition now for almost 12 yrs.
Even if a guys has some L's, even devastating L's, if they come back strong like Wlad, Miguel, Pac, etc......IMO, they are immune to criticism.:deal

 

Kell Brooks resume is irrefutably top 10 WW, all time.

 

SALVADOR SANCHEZ:
02/80: Danny Lopez (Champion) [42-3, 39 KO] TKO13
04/80: Ruben Castillo (#2) [47-1, 24 KO] UD15
06/80: Danny Lopez (#1-3) [42-4, 39 KO] TKO14
09/80: Patrick Ford (N/A, #5 for '81) [16-0, 10 KO] MD15
12/80: Juan LaPorte (N/A, #8 for '81) [15-1, 8 KO] UD15
03/81: Roberto Castanon (#6) [43-1, 24 KO] TKO10
07/81: Nicky Perez (@130) [50-3] UD10
08/81: Wilfredo Gomez (#1) [32-0, 32 KO] TKO8
12/81: Pat Cowdell (N/A, #8 for '82) [19-2, 7 KO] SD15
05/82: Jorge Garcia (N/A) [23-2] UD15
07/82: Azumah Nelson (N/A, #6 for '83) [13-0] TKO15

Lopez, Gomez and Nelson are all comfortably enshrined in the HOF.

In the case of Castillo, he'd only suffered one defeat and it was to Arguello @ 130. In the case of LaPorte, he'd continue climbing the ratings in the immediate following years and claim a portion of the title; Castanon's only defeat was to Lopez whom Sanchez stopped twice. Wilfredo Gomez was moving up (4 LBS) but was a 2-to-1 favorite. Azumah Nelson didn't lose again for 8 years.

Yeh, Pretty Fuuckin Good Record.

 

This.

 

The lack of blueprint is irrefutable.