I dont know **** about those weight classes, especially in this period tbh, but how do you see a fantasy match up between Khaosai Galaxy and Harada?
The question I ask of fighters with limited fights at the top, Harada answered at BW. He passed the tests I'd want a divisional GOAT to pass. That performance in the first fight vs Kingpetch was electrifying, Harada was a force of nature in there. I don't throw out the rematch, but I do think Harada was short-changed and Kingpetch was brilliant in rematches, anyway. I don't think anyone has an easy time beating Kingpetch in a rematch, in Thailand. And I don't massively worry too much about the first Medel fight, because Medel was a very good fighter and a massive puncher. I don't think there's a flyweight stand-in for him, who'd do that sort of a job on Harada. And I don't know whether there's any flyweight who hits quite that hard, apart from maybe Wilde. If we're throwing around the names which circle the top of the flyweight division (with a healthy amount of footage) we're talking Canto, Oba, Chionoi, Chocolatito, Laciar, etc. I feel that Harada from the first fight (where from what I can gather, he didn't have quite so many issues with making the weight) is the best bet to beat any of these. I reckon he'd overpower a good few of these, outworking them and subjugating them with superior physicality. Guys like Oba, Choco and Chionoi would have a hard time getting his respect, fending him off and taking what he had to give out IMO. It's a big ask. Stylistically, he's pretty bad for Canto, and that sort of ritzy out-boxer. The guys with limited/no footage could potentially provide harder tasks. Wilde seems pretty bad for Harada - that's a bad match-up; Wolgast was a phenom in a similar vein to Harada, himself - he's got a good shot vs anybody; Villa, Lynch and Genaro are tough mutha****ers who you probably shouldn't brawl with; and being hyper aggressive vs Kane probably isn't advised; Pascual Perez's razor-sharp punching and freakish dynamism could potentially cause an upset as well. I don't think anyone goes undefeated vs that lot. I do think that the physical tank I saw vs Pone - who's intangibles were tested later on - was good enough to beat any of them on the right night. And if he lost, he'd likely lose fewer fights than the rest of them. IMO.
Galaxy was a monster physically, a huge puncher and a southpaw. He could potentially beat Harada, but I tend to think Harada's jab, skills and footwork would just lead to him constantly staying one step ahead and being a bit more of an aggressive out-boxer he was in the Medel rematch, rather than the killer bee he was in their first fight.
Great post George, on one of my favourite fighters too. Little trivia for you - the nickname 'Fighting' is treated as a 'missing' nickname in the JBC, and no active fighter is allowed to use it out of respect to Harada. Regarding your commentary on the 'Three Crows' specifically (for those not familiar, these were Masahiko Harada, Hiroyuki Ebihara and Katsutoshi Aoki, the three top prospects at the time, who all competed in / around the same divisions and were all touted for the world). I do believe Harada was being modest, however there is some truth to what he says, at least in my opinion. Aoki was known, at least from what I've read, as a major talent with a big punch and major arrogance. However, he was a massive, massive drinker, allegedly abused sleeping pills, hated training - he was known to pour water on his head during roadwork, and would even skip sparring sessions - and had a troubled background since his early teens in a juvenile prison. As a consequence, he had several losses and uninspiring wins to lesser talented but hard training boxers. Still, he became the Oriental Champion and was basically a 'kill or be killed' Boxer in his style approach, as you can see on film. Eventually he attempted suicide, was charged with multiple crimes and was in trouble with the law often, before suffering with alcoholism in his later years. Here's a translated quote on him from Japanese wiki, 'To dispel fear, he sometimes drank alcohol until dawn on the day of the match and went up to the ring with the smell of alcohol . Even in the match against Harada, he testified that he was drinking until the morning of the match and still thought he could win.' Ebihara was also a freak with the guts and training to back it up. Harada himself stated that Ebihara was a genius, and many influential figures, such as Eddie Townsend, commented on his high natural ability, sense of rhythm and mental toughness. He was known for his power and 'razor punching' and iirc he has the second highest amount of KOs ever by a Japanese fighter, with a lot over quality opponents. Harada physically seemed to deal with Ebihara early, which is weird as Ebihara was 3 years older, so you could argue Harada was more physcially developed early rather than 'purely talented'. In their fight, Harada troubled him style wise and downed him twice with mad rushes, but apparently Ebihara came on towards the end with counters. Ebihara also frequently injured his hands, with lasting impact, and was also known for blowing in some bouts but pacing himself very well. In the end, Ebihara also became an alcoholic and eventually died of liver problems. His daughter died in a car accident years before. Harada, in my opinion, was the hardest training and had the most spirit of any of them towards his fighting. He was super talented as well, of course. Boxing was his life whilst he was active. Like Chris said, 110%. It also helped he was the best schooled of the three, with Harada's training / gym lineage going directly back to the 'father of Japanese Boxing' Yujiro Watanabe (born 1889) through the leader of his gym, Takeshi Sasazaki, who had 115 bouts. Harada had a good foundation for his debut, better than Ebihara (whose gym was literally a converted stable in the beginning). I believe Chris said Harada was also trained by a family member from his Q&A to Harada. Harada seemed to define the ideal Japanese mentality of that time - massive spirit, immense stamina and unrelenting patience in discipline. In fact, the more I hear of Harada's training, the more I think he is one the hardest trainers ever. Simply freakish alongside incredible skill developments. Harada was known to struggle with his weight, with some sources saying his weight would go as high as 65kg (which I think is large exaggeration). Still, he was known for having to go on strict diets etc due to a sweet tooth. All in all, Harada is undeniably Japan's best fighter, both legacy wise and H2H. However, I do not think he is their most 'talented' to come along, with Watanabe and Tatsuyoshi filling that role for me.
It might depend where those flyweight fights happened. As McGrain says, the sample size for Harada at the weight is minute and he himself admitted he was intimidated in a foreign environment. The crowd really helped in Japan and he was majestic in that first fight with Kingpetch, but Canto at his peak may have had a little too much know-how to be beaten like that. Perez also in his prime may have caught Harada rushing in in ways Pone didn’t in that fight. I can see a prime Chocolatito edging him too as his output is phenomenal and the best of Chocolatito at the weight is more refined than the best of Harada at the weight. It’s possible if all these top flyweights flight head other twice, perhaps those three I mentioned suffer the least amount of losses as I am sure Harada can beat anyone but may lose a few. He definitely peaked at bantam where he learned to pace himself better (he was tired in Kingpetch II) and learned how to recover from being stung. His boxing got better but at flyweight he was stronger than most. I’m not the biggest fan of mythicals so I can see where George is coming from with his h2h talk but the sample size is small and I do agree he was robbed in Thailand but his limitations (at that weight) were evident in the second half of the match. I also see McGrains point of very little action vs. ranked foes at the weight. That’s why im far more comfortable ranking him at bantam and hypothesizing how he’d do against other greats.
Panama Al lived an interesting life which ultimately became tragic while still in his relative youth. The first Latino world champion, they tried everything to stop him. To be Latino, black AND gay in that time!! Had a lengthy relationship with Jean Cocteau too. Just a crazy story overall. As a fighter he was great. Considering he often was undertrained and then later entered the ring very sick so often and to never be KO’d in that many fights is a miracle. Nightmare style head-to-head too. A very, very tall bantam who could fight you inside and take a shot. That’s tough.
He did, but at a time in his career after which he never made bantamweight again. And perhaps couldn't have without hurting himself and his swarming, high intensity performance. In other words, your proof that he was flyweight divisional number one was presented at a time when he was no longer a flyweight. I see it a bit with Ali sometimes - guys want to have him fast and a genius all at once, first and second career credited at the same time. But he never was. Harada clearly improved after he left the division and we have proof of that beyond what we see (though we can see his improvement on film as time passes, too). I mean he actually changed his style, or at least broadened it. Harada got better. The idea that a pre-prime version of Harada on twenty odd fights is going to do better against the field than versions of guys like Midget Wolgast on 80 fights or 40-0 Gonzalez...just nah. He was too vulnerable for that kind of detail back in that day. And I agree with a lot of what you say about his performance versus Kingpetch but Kingpetch was made for him. I mean of the guys you'd want Harada in with out of the guys scratching around in "the field", he's the one. You're right about Medel too, an excellent fighter, but he also taught Harada his second to last lesson - the idea that this guy, who had real lessons to learn from Medel and Jofre before he reached his absolute best is the single best flyweight of all time - just nah. Not at all for me. It's kind of a horrifying idea tbh. I wouldn't consider Harada nor Kingpetch a top ten head-to-head fly. They might make a top thirty. I would probably pick Estrada to beat Harada at fly. He had so much to learn.
Here is some Harada in brilliant quality. HD clip of Harada vs Rudkin (best quality I've ever seen of Harada, actually - @AlFrancis have you seen this?): This content is protected "Japan's Strongest Champion Fighting Harada" - again, in very high quality (long video): This content is protected Extended highlight of the 'Crazy Windmill' Fighting Harada, also in HD: This content is protected Fighting Harada - interview and coaching children: This content is protected
Also, for those wondering why there are HQ clips and extended highlights, but not full fights, it's because they seem to get removed, and the channel deleted, if uploaded. I don't know what the reason is. If you see one, however, you should download it quickly.
Weird, ain't it? Possibly the TV stations that own the original footage. Japan is funny about stuff like that. There's no copyright infringement detected by youtube, so it must be reported manually. They don't seem to care about the LQ versions, though. Maybe the HQ versions are on a DVD to buy, or only for specific uses. I was gonna upload my own rips till I realised all the channels I'd gotten them off had been deleted, the videos removed. Fighting Harada would be more likely to get my channel removed than copyrighted music or movies
Great stuff that, seen the first one with the different camera angle on the AP archive in the past but haven't seen the others. It would be great if there was a full version with that other camera. Love to know what the Champ was saying about me dad on the long video.
Don't want to tempt fate but I posted the full version in Japanese 9 years ago without any problems so far. It's a shame there aren't more views for it. I posted the English highlight version 11 years with no problem but it's bad quality. I do have the original 16mm of that so maybe I'll look into getting it cleaned up. On the other hand I posted the Rudkin Rose fight in it's entirety 11 years ago but that was taken down after a copyright infringement query by the Australian tv station. I got two or 3 strikes for that because it was in 15min sections and a threat to close my account. Luckily someone else uploaded it a couple of years later and it's still there far as I know