Fight's that Roach's Fighters Lost

Hopkins vs callzaghe
Odlh vs mayweather

All close fights and roach had 1camp with both fighters.

 

The DLH gameplan that worked until the jab disappeared actually impressed me in terms of his intelligence.

A trainer takes a lot of responsibility for performance, but he's not the one in the ring.

 

Roach didn't train concepcion for the Juanma fight. Atleast he wasn't in his corner for that one. I remember being surprised not seeing him.

 

Vazquez/Marquez I
Viloria/Nino I
Bautista/Deleon
Sidornko/Darchinyan


MMA: Arlovski vs. Fedor

 

Penalosa/JuanMa

 

Morales W12 Pacquiao
Marquez `L12` Pacquiao
Calzaghe W12 Hopkins
Mayweather W12 DLH
Mayweather W12 Pacquiao

Spring to mind first.

 

Things that got me thinking he's not a great a trainer:
A few of his fighters have tested positive for steroids. The shining example is James Toney, which upon the news being broken, Roach said something extremely close to "we didn't think the steroids would still be in his system by fight night." So when this scumbag tried saying 9 months ago about "I don't know what a steroid looks like or what it does," I lose all respect for him.
Freddie Roach = Grima Wormtongue

 

Did Roach ever train James Toney to a loss?

 

This. But that doesn't mean he's not that great of a trainer to me. You can be the best trainer and your fighter decides do his own thing in the ring or cannot execute the gameplan. I think Freddy is a great trainer.

 

did'nt freddie roach work with michael moorer for the holyfield rematch.

 

Most people overlook this because he trains the golden child now. That effects my outlook on him as a trainer far more than his fighters losing some fights.

 

Tyson - Williams ???