the truth is we'll never know because of what happened after the Chavez fight. I'm sure that if he had won that fight, if he had lasted those 20 last seconds without getting knocked down, the world would have been his oyster.
The problem was that Meldrick was a Philly fighter. Like Frazier he didn't know when to let go of something. He got too 'involved'.
Good and accurate post. If he could have remained at 140 for the majority of his career he could have stayed successful for quite a while, but there were too many piranhas at 147 for a shortish guy with a tendency to get hit. The Taylor of the McGirt-Chavez years was outstanding though. Could you imagine someone like Hatton winning even a ROUND off that guy? I can't.
Taylor was amazing, he gave JCC his hardest prime yrs fight & came as close as you can to winning without doing so. If you give that guy a good defence he wouldnt be as exciting but his career would certainly have lasted longer & his talents would rightfully be recognized as ATG material. Only Chavez could have come thru what he did that night of all 140 champions Ive seen... perhaps Pryor could also but without winning. Taylor just poured it on constantly for 11 + rds, amazing.
your referring to ONE fight the Chavez fight, Taylor had that issue in every fight, he would continue to slug with lesser fighter and take shots that he should not have.
It was a very bad luck to fight chavez that night, that day not even Pryor beats Chavez It's the only fight in the prime Chavez era that he was over matched for 11 rounds, I remember a post-fight interview with Chavez saying that in order to connect 1 he had to take 3