First 31 fights who had a better record Bradley or Floyd?

Floyd, by a reasonable margin

 

So Marquez and Bradley ranks higher that Floyd as an ATG?

 

2 division lineal champ vs. 2 division titlist

Corrales, Castillo II, and Genaro are a far better top tier than Marquez + any 2 others Bradley has beaten.

People forget that guys like C. Hernandez, Chavez, and Manfredy were all top 10 mainstays for several years at Super Feather when Floyd beat them.

I chose not to include the Pacquiao I fight here because I did not score it for Bradley and it wasn't even really all that close. For the sake of fairness and to prevent whining, I have also chosen to not factor in Floyds' razor close yet great win over Castillo in their first fight despite scoring it for him, as I can acknowledge that a good percentage of folks came up with tie scores or ones against him.

 

Bradley

Plus he's modest and decent, a proper champ.

 

wasnt there some controversy with floyds win over chavez , up on the scorecards and quit due to tiredness or somethin

 

atsch

Nope, Floyd beat the **** out of him

Floyd was winning wide then they had to stop it because Chavez took way too much punishment from PBF! :deal

 

It was quite the war, actually. Or maybe an "almost war." I'd recommend to watch it. One of the most exciting/competitive of Floyds' career.

I only gave Chavez 2 rounds IIRC, although it's been a while since I watched it start to finish. He was getting tagged flush and hard repeatedly for several rounds late leading to the stoppage (one of Floyds' best offensive exhibitions). He was fading out. No controversy at all.

If one of his early fights were then the Carlos Hernandez fight would be most slightly controversial, I suppose, as Hernandez seemed to deserve a closer points loss than the judges credited him with (this was the famous "fractured hand" knockdown fight).

 

ye might have a look at it , i just remember someone mentioniing it on here

 

The only controversy in stopping the Chavez fight is that it was exciting and fans wanted Chavez to have a chance to continue...

 

Floyd, Bradley didn't beat Pacquiao.