stylewise, Mayweather is a guy who would beat Chavez easily enough and Duran even easier. The style would not be good for either guy.
Duran was a better boxer than Mayweather. He would outbox him. Chavez would outwork Mayweather and beat him on points or a late stoppage.
Bull **** not all torn rotator cuff need surgery. It depends on the severity of the injury. I myself had slight tear in my rotator cuff in my left shoulder from hitting a 200lb heavy bag with speed mits. The worse that happen I was not able to train for 4 to 5 month, this included weight and shadow boxing.
u guys aint learned the ESB rule? Floyd CANT win against any past ATG....NONE!!! Even if you think it will be competitive ur a ***** :deal
Considering the trouble Floyd had with Jesus Chavez and Jose Luis Castillo, and considering that JC Chavez is basically a vastly superior version in every way of those two guys, I think Chavez has the perfect style and attributes to outfight Floyd over the course and pound his way to a unanimous decision. There aren't many fighters I'd back to beat Floyd at 140, but Chavez is one of the only ones, stylistically he's horrible for Floyd.
at 140 I favor PBF at 135 I favor Chavez PBF didn'thave a good run at 135 so it's hard to match him up against the greats at lightweight. Floyd's hands were **** at that time in his career. He also didn't really master the shoulder roll until the N'dou fight imo, which was his last fight at 135.