Floyd Mayweather jr. vs Pernell Whitaker: Who you rate higher p4p and who beats who h2h?

There is no way Mosley was pound for pound in 2010_at that age give it a rest. List the Ring magazines pound for pound in 2010 and Mosley isn't on any list.

 

From Google:
In early 2010, Sugar Shane Mosley was ranked as high as No. 3 in The Ring magazine's pound-for-pound list. However, following his loss to Floyd Mayweather Jr. in May 2010, Mosley was dropped from the pound-for-pound rankings by September 2010.
He was Number 3 on Feb and April and dropped to Number 5 after losing to Floyd.

 

Wrong. Here it is Rings pound for pound 2010:

1. Pac
2.Mayweather
3.Sergio Martinez
4.Juan Marquez
5.Donarie
6.Wonjonkam
7.Montiel
8.Klitschko
9.Bradley
10.Juan Manuel Lopez







4.

 

In the eight bouts AFTER Mayweather Mosley went 3-4-1. So tell me are you going to tell me he was PRIME or even close to it vs Mayweather?

 

ouch! you gave him a standing 8 count with this one.

 

What month here's the ranking in April:
[url]https://web.archive.org/web/20100409004224/http://www.doghouseboxing.com/Ring/Ring040510.htm[/url]
The top 10 pound-for-pound rankings for April 5, 2010, were:

1. Manny Pacquiao (51–3–2, 38 KOs) – Light Welterweight (The Ring), Welterweight (WBO)
2. Floyd Mayweather Jr. (40–0, 25 KOs) – Welterweight
3. Shane Mosley (46–5, 39 KOs) – Welterweight (WBA Super)
4. Juan Manuel Márquez (50–5–1, 37 KOs) – Lightweight (WBA Super, WBO, The Ring)
5. Nonito Donaire (23–1, 15 KOs) – Super Flyweight
6. Bernard Hopkins (51–5–1–1, 32 KOs) – Light Heavyweight
7. Miguel Cotto (34–2, 27 KOs) – Welterweight
8. Chad Dawson (29–0, 17 KOs) – Light Heavyweight
9. Paul Williams (38–1, 27 KOs) – Light Middleweight
10. Celestino Caballero (33–2, 23 KOs) – Super Bantamweight (WBA Super)

By May 4, 2010, Mosley had moved to the No. 5 position.

The top 10 pound-for-pound rankings for May 4, 2010, were:

1. Manny Pacquiao (51–3–2, 38 KOs) – Light Welterweight (The Ring), Welterweight (WBO)
2. Floyd Mayweather Jr. (41–0, 25 KOs) – Welterweight
3. Juan Manuel Márquez (50–5–1, 37 KOs) – Lightweight (WBA Super, WBO, The Ring)
4. Nonito Donaire (23–1, 15 KOs) – Super Flyweight
5. Shane Mosley (46–6, 39 KOs) – Welterweight (WBA Super)
6. Chad Dawson (29–0, 17 KOs) – Light Heavyweight
7. Paul Williams (38–1, 27 KOs) – Middleweight
8. Sergio Martínez (45–2–2, 24 KOs) – Middleweight (WBC, WBO, The Ring)
9. Pongsaklek Wonjongkam (75–3–1, 39 KOs) – Flyweight (WBC, The Ring)
10. Celestino Caballero (34–2, 23 KOs) – Super Bantamweight (WBA Super)

 

Not my argument I literally just gave you the facts that yes Mosley was ranked third on Rings PfP ranking

 

So was he close or near his prime vs MAYWEATHER YES OR NO?

 

Was he P4P number 3 when he fought Mayweather? You're shifting the argument because you know you were wrong just admit it bro

 

He was not pound for pound number 3. He hadn't been in the pound for pound for YEARS.
Now answer the question was he PRIME,close to it, or was he SHOT?

 

He was as I showed even gave you evidence for it which you're now ignoring for some reason.......

 

Right and your answer if Mosley was in his prime or close to it for May weather was......... he was WAY past his prime as he showed by losing most of his remaining bouts.
But hey he went from being the THIRD BEST BOXER in the entire world to being a totally shot boxer unable to post any good wins in ONE YEAR.

 

Again that was never my argument just concede you were wrong and he was ranked third before the fight and we can go our separate ways

 

He was not ranked third. I actually have those issues and will dig them out tomorrow and look.

 

I literally gave you a source and posted the list like bro........