Floyd Mayweather jr. vs Pernell Whitaker: Who you rate higher p4p and who beats who h2h?

No I was being facetious. The first part is more likely.

 

He was shot. Name me a good/great fighter Shane beat AFTER Mayweather. Matter of fact what was his record after his bout with Mayweather?

 

Lightweight: Pea wins
Welterweight: Mayweather wins
P4P: They’re both around the top 25 spot

 

Mayweather for both. I actually think Pernell would make Floyd look dumb in the ring but he’d just play too much and lose on points.

 

That's the most reasonable post I've read in here, IMO. I think Whitaker takes the lightest weight and Mayweather the highest. Lets call it a split trilogy at 140.

 

I think Pea is both the better fighter in terms of sheer ability and would win the fight between them.

Pea wins at 135, 140 and 147. He probably loses at 154, I think.

Floyd ranks higher all time if we go by official results. Pernell ranks slightly higher if we give him the Ramirez 1, Chavez and Oscar bouts (which he absolutely won btw)

 

Thanks JT. I think it helps that I don’t have a horse in this race - very much respect both fighters’ accomplishments but was never really a fan of either of them.

 

Totally agree mate.