Floyd Mayweather vs. Ricky Hatton @ 140.

Floyd would win easily. Simple really

 

I think the fight would have been more competitive than their actual fight. (which was still pretty close for the first 6 plus rounds despite clearly prejudicial bias by the referee)

But, beating Ricky Hatton in and of itself, does not automatically qualify a fighter for top ten anything.

 

PBF beats Hatton worse at 140 than he did at 147. PBF was faster and had better movement at 140 than he did at 147.

 

i guess their fight was competitive for a little while though in actuality i never once thought floyd wasn't in total control and just biding his time. i see no reason why this would be any different at 140. floyd easy.

 

This. It would be the same result.

 

I got a better one. Porter vs Hatton and the fight was in Britain where they allowed Ricky to fight his Grappling style? Floyd would’ve killed Hatton at 140.

 

Would be a HIDEOUS fight of grappling and smothering of each guy's own work. Gross.

 

What fights would you judge this on, he barely fought at that weight !!!

 

More interesting proposal:

Pacquiao Vs. Hatton @ 147?

 

His speed of both hand and foot at that weight was noticeably faster. He fought guys closer to his size at that weight guys at 147 were usually always bigger than him and because of that had more pop at 140. IMO 140 could have been his best weight if he stayed in the division longer. Gatti and Bruseles fights come to mind

 

Hatton beat Tszyu at 140 and then lost to Collazo at 147. He was a weight bully like Jeff Horn at 147. Put Jeff in at 154 and he's got nothing.

 

More competitive how? Floyd wouldn't have had to drain himself to make 140, and Hatton didn't have to drain himself that much to make 147.

 

Hatton was THERE when Floyd fought Gatti. He didn't look good after that fight, who would be after seeing the p4p king put on a performance like that?

Cotto was also there and he looked sick to his stomach.

 

Same thing with Margarito. Daniel Santos proved that.