No, because he's a counter puncher and Shane's work rate doubles his. Winky would be too menacing with the jab and the size disparity. When has floyd looked good against a south paw? let alone one who could jab the bejesus out of him.
If you say so. I think looking good against shot mitchell doesn't mean much. He got rocked by judah and corley.
I'd favor Winky. His height and reach advantages, combined with his air tight D and quick hard jab would probably see him take a decision versus Floyd.
i can see that, i mean with him putting on pounds it would only slow lil floyd down........but floyd does counter the jab well
He still looked good against Mitchell and he still beat the hell out of Corley and Judah. Trinidad was floored against David Reid, are you going to tell me he didn't look good in that fight?
Got rocked? Good boxers are supposed to "rock" their opponent in every fight they are in. It's not Floyd's fault he is so dominant that most fighters don't land **** on him. Floyd beat both of these guys very easily. Mayweather UD over Winky. Damn Floyd is underrated by the haters around here.
It isn't hate when you think a guy who is very skilled and is considerably larger would win, it is an opinion.