Floyd Mayweather's best performance at 140 or 147?

140 is Gatti obviously.


147 would probably be Hatton.

 

best performance was against trex carralez. fight that made pedjr atg:rofl

 

140 is gatti by far

147 id go with hatton or mosley

 

best performance has been ducking pacman

 

140: Gatti for sure. Corley is highly underrated. Both these fights were offensive exhibitions.

147: Got to be Marquez or Hatton. I'd go with beating Marquez by 13 points in a 12 rounder at a weight he would go on to make big noise at... He's got a lot of other real solid top wins at WW, but all of them could be argued to be behind his three victories up at JMW.

 

I wouldn't really call the Marquez fight a big win..

Sure, Marquez was the p4p number 2 fighter in the world and sure Mayweather was at a year and a half layoff..

But Marquez is 3-1 at WW and was the Lightweight champion of the world during the Mayweather bout.


I'd honestly rate the Judah win higher than the Marquez win.

 

beating marquez, is like pac beating rigo at c/w between 135 and 140 and pac not honoring the c/w.

hows that sound? good win for pac?

 

I was going to say Oscar, but I just remembered that bout was at 154.

Handing Hatton his first stoppage. Mosley also deserves a mention, given his early scare.

At 140, Artoro Gatti would fit the bill. While never at the very top of world level, Gatti was a formidable opponent and Floyd utterly dismantled him in a one-sided beatdown.

 

Gatti/Marquez

 

@ 140 - It's Gatti.

@ 147 - It's Marquez.

 

Gatti at 140, Baldomir at 147

 

gatti easy and ruining the rest of ssm was classic.
ssm was what about Floyd age now ?