Who have a better resume really? IMO Floyd got this. He fought more primed opponents and bigger opposition and won them all. Tito fought more big names but unfortunely most of them were out of prime much like Oscar De La Hoya. Past prime notables Floyd's Hernandez to Trinidad's Camacho Floyd's Oscar to Trinidad's Whitaker Floyd's Baldomir to Trinidad's Mayorga Floyd's Gatti to Trinidad's Campas Not so good notables Floyd's N'dou was in prime as well as Sosa to Trinidad's Reid and Thiam Floyd's Corley to Trinidad's Carr Floyd's Chavez to Trinidad's Joppy Elites Floyd's Corrales to Trinidad's Vargas Floyd's Castillo 2x (peaking Prime) to Trinidad's bhop (semi prime) and Wright (semi prime) Floyd's Hatton (prime) to Trinidad's (out of prime Jones) Floyd has also beaten a prime Judah and prime Carlos Henderaz Tito fought more big names but most definitely not the most dangerous.
The Gatti and Campas comparison is horrible All you have to do is look at the odds before the fights to know what a bad comparision that is. When Tito fought Campas, Campas was 56-0 (mostly by KO) and favored to beat Tito. He was considered to be a very dangerous opponent. when Floyd fought Gatti he was like a 10 to one favorite and Gatti was at the end of a career where he had a ton of losses (some to very mediocre fighters)
I don't really have links (I know shame on me). I just usually remember the numbers leading into fights because they almost always mention them during the telecast or on bosing sites before the fight.
These are fighters not real-estate, u cannot do comprables like this. What is the point anyway? Trinidad was a great fighter Mayweather is a great fighter. For my entertainment value Trinidad was always more exciting to watch than Floyd. They have very different styles and skill sets. but given a choice I would watch Trinidad anyday.
