Floyd will go down as the most overrated boxer in history

hattons younger than him

and if its in the last five years so is judah

also these are his decent wins

Shane Mosley
Carlos Baldomir
Ricky Hatton
Zab Judah
Oscar De La Hoya
Sharmba Mitchell
Arturo Gatti
Jose Luis Castillo
Genaro Hernandez
Diego Corrales
DeMarcus Corley
Carlos Hernandez
Jesus Chavez
Ill stick Juan Manuel Marquez in there as he was so soundly technicaly beaten (not just overpowered).. although he was no where near his best weight

 

U forgot:-
Zero balls, maximum vagina

He's a dog! His a gorilla!

 

To be overrated, you have to be very highly thought of. Hatton isn't universally rated high, unlike fighters like Pac, Floyd, DLH, Tito...who were.

 

im saying age wise

cant really argue with the other points

when they fought hatton was rated highley btw

 

but... when was the last time pacman beat anyone younger than him or in his prime? oh yeah and watch the JMM fights.

 

right behind de la hoya, pacquiao and kelly pavlik.

 

Hatton was undefeated when they fought

Mosley just ko'd margarito

 

He's the most overrated for the simple fact that so many claim that he's unbeatable, and pick him in most head to head matchups against greats. He's no where near as good as people believe he is. He's fought easy competition. Aside from a prime Castillo (who most believe beat him), an old over the hill Hoya (who got a split decision) and an old, shot looking Mosley who almost decapitated him. People need to get their head checked on this dude. He has only once or twice faced any kind of real threat. Pacquiao would expose him if they ever fight.

 

you call and undefeated hatton and corrales easy? what about mosley... was he easy? and if he was easy or old why was roach afraid to put his guy in with him? and why is pacman fighting the guy he lost to? things that make ya go hmmmmm!

 

mayweather is a legitimate top 50 all time fighter. bottom end but still pretty impressive. to say he's top 40 is reasonable, top 30 is a farce and top 20 insulting to real legends.

it depends on where you put him. if i were to sit down, i'd have him around 40 but to each their own. only overrated if you have to justify his post gatti career as anything but cashing in and making himself known

 

dumb post of the day. pac fought all of this guys leftovers, and ran from a guy floyd just beat, but you say he would expose floyd.:rofl:rofl:roflatschatsch

 

That old shot looking Mosley would have been just as easy for Pacquiao, if not easier.

Undefeated Hatton? Yeah who fought out of his weight class and went 10 rounds with Floyd, and got his ass knocked out in two by Pacquiao (at his weight).

Corrales was a good win, but he isn't an ATG.

His resume speaks for itself bro. Hardly any real threats on there. Everybody slower, or older. Whenever he did face somewhat of a true threat he was made to look ordinary.

 

Floyd's resume doesn't stack up when comparing him with fighters throughout history.