Discussion in 'General Boxing Forum' started by Boxlight, Feb 16, 2017.
but do you think he truly won the first fight?
He did better than Broner but worse than Devon.
I don't know... I think it could've been a draw. The first fight I mean.
Floyd by 2 or 3 rounds i think watching it live.
From watching highlights it appears maidanas offense was not exactly effective as much as we thought
Draw (Edit: for the FIRST fight).
There's CERTAINLY a case for a Maidana victory as any two Flomos disagree with regards to what rounds they give to Maidana.
Yes he did.
Yes but could he beat Anne Wolfe?
I had Floyd by 1 or 2 rounds. Close first fight
First was close but I think he definitely won. Second fight showed the levels
I'd say a draw was a very legit score. Maidana is the only fighter to rightfully have a draw in an official card as Oscar's lone card and Canelo lone even card were bad judging
no real case for a Maidana W however
Floyd won the rematch but Maidana still won a few
What rounds do you give to Maidana
He hates Floyd look at post and thread history he deals in hypothetical losses
I really don't remember tbh, what rounds did you give to Maidana?
Maidana in their first fight won a solid few rounds and was competitive in many that he lost. Not something that anyone other than Castillo ever did against Floyd.
Never kept a scorecard.
Just interesting how you say there's a strong argument Maidana when you can't say which rounds you give him.