Floyd's ATG Status by Weight Class!

Mosley was unbeaten at 135 and has a better record there than PBF. So he is more dominant.

Mosley was faster than PBF at 135, therefore greater. He hit harder too, therefore greater.

Glad we cleared that up, now that I know what you're judging by. :deal

 

:good

To play the devil's advocate role, though, it CAN be argued that beating Castillo twice at lightweight is better than anything Mosely ever did there...

Although Mosely was a recking machine at 135

 

Oh, so now you're talking 'all-time' again, or are you using the term 'all-time' to refer to fighters who fought at 135 at the same time PBF fought at 135? :deal

What do you have 5 masters in? :deal

 

But he isn't using resume. He says accomplishments are not part of his criteria.

 

What, too hard for you?

I thought so :yep

What do you have 5 masters degrees in? :deal

Let me guess:

1. Making Rocks
2. Smoking Rocks
3. Dealing with Rock Addiction
4. Kicking Rocks
5. Dealing with being an offspring of Rock Addicts

Prove me wrong :deal

 

What do you have 5 masters degrees in? :deal

Go on, answer me that, (I've only been asking you for 4 pages) and I'll answer you yours :hey

 

that second quote just sums dumbtime up :rofl

 

I agree that the quote is a terrible quote. But is it really worth 43 damn pages to discuss? Neither is gonna drop it, so this is just gonna go on and on and on. Save yourself the trouble.

 

It's probably every bit as worthy as 200 pages of Lewis vs Klit round 7 speculation or the Golota express. I'm just sayin....

 

'beaten' or achieved more at 135? :deal

You have to be clearer on your criteria dumbtime.

You claimed PBF to be #3 ATG at 135 based on 4 fights at that weight, 3 title defences, and your opinion that he was the most dominant champ at 135 since Sweet Pea

How is that possible when he only defended his title 3 times? :rofl

What do you have 5 masters degrees in? :deal

 

And I know what your sayin'. But wouldn't this board be better without it? And wouldn't this thread be better if we could LEGIMATELY argue who is better at 135, Shane or Floyd? Without having 4 pages interupt it with two guys having an argument over the net