As you'll notice, some of the fighters are named more than once as it's simply a better matchup compared to others faced at that weight (Example: Castillo at LW for Floyd). The fighters are going against each other in the state and condition they were at when they faced either Floyd or Whitaker. Also note, I know Pea didn't fight Nelson at SFW, but Nelson is a SFW fighter really, and so is Corrales, so I thought it would be a good matchup. SFW: Nelson vs. Corrales LW: Ramirez vs. Castillo Roger May vs. Castillo Brazier vs. Castillo Super LW: Pineda vs Mitchell WW: McGirt vs. Manny P Chavez vs. Hatton Rivera vs. Ortiz Oscar vs. Manny P. Guerrero vs. Hurtado Super WW: Vasquez vs. Cotto Vasquez vs. Alvarez
I think Oscar would probably beat Vazquez at 154. I also think Mosley, Zab, and Marquez would beat Rivera and possibly Hurtado. Long story short, the opponents would split a lot of these and it's a confusing concept.
