Floyd's Better Win : Mosley or Cotto ???

Only if you have seen a fighter who was labeled shot 3 years ago then became unshot after successful fights with B fighters.

 

cotto was an better opponent than shane and floyd won in an exciting fashion.

 

Whoever said Cotto was shot in the first place is a ****in idiot. Shot fighters can't move, cant pull the trigger, can't get out of the way of a punch, can't throw with power, can't take a punch, so on and so forth. Cotto can still do all those things, some of them very well.
Cotto got two ass whoopin's before the Mayweather fight and came back, he's not ****in shot. People will say anything to fit their agenda, its pathetic.

 

I agree here too. While I myself didn't hold the same view of Cotto's "shotness" post Pac and Margarito beatdowns, the public perception was still there undeniably

 

It is difficult to say. This bit about Ring's ranking of Mosley is a bit of a poor argument though. That was a self-serving, silly-ass p4p ranking from Ring. Cotto proved the bigger challenge, possibly as a matter of styles, but keep in mind that the weight of history falls much heavier on Mosley's name than Cotto's despite how you would assess the two at the time and place they were defeated.

 

i clicked on the wrong one

i meant mosley.

just because people said floyd were scared of mosley and he proved them wrong.

also mosley was the #1 ww and #3 p4p fighter at the time.

 

Poll results are surprising.

 

shane was a great win. but cotto was a much bigger win than that.

 

Mosley was barely a 3/1 underdog. Some in the media gave Mosley a serious chance. Many thought Floyd was forced to take this fight.

Cotto was a 7/1 underdog and no one gave him a chance. The only question was how he loses.

Mosley had come off his destruction of Margarito and was #3 p4p. Sure, the *****s will have u believe Cotto was somehow this new fighter but it is what it is. He was brutally beaten twice. The fact that the fight was at 154 helps but they are very close in size.

How on Earth is the Cotto win better?

 

I'll say both wins are on par with eachother.

 

good wins but really nothing to gloat about.