Former Boxing News Editor list his top 25 boxers of the last 25 years

Pacquiao > Mayweather p4p

 

If you scored the Trindad and at least Mosley 2 against Oscar, why should anyone value your opinion on boxing?


Oscar took the risks, he fought them all. He proved he was better in the ring than most, even if the judges were watching something else.

 

Which former Boxing News editor made this list ..... is it Claude Abrams?

 

That list is horrific.

Cotto and Mooreer aren't top 45 much less 25
They also seemingly ignored everything below featherweight(Nonito, Wonjongkam, H. Gonzalez, R.Gonzlez, R. Marquez)
Not to mention Winky Wright and Terry Norris

 

If michael moorer is in that list then so should George Foreman.

 

JC Chavez without a doubt.

 

I think this guy made a mistake. Wlad should be #7 instead of #17.

 

I'm surprised I'm the only vote for Hopkins. Career greatness should be about record, quality of scalps, consistency, and longevity, not peak pound-for-pound ability. So I think despite how great Roy looked for a few years and his win over him Hopkins deserves the accolades as the greater fighter.

Rafael Marquez, Tapia, Calderon, Mark Johnson, Winky Wright at least deserve to be above Michalczweski. Roman Gonzalez is every bit as deserving as current fighters Floyd, Pac, Ward, Wlad Klitschko.

 

LOL Wladimir and Vitali below Miguel Cotto and Erik Morales?

 

Lopez was not better than Chavez and Whitaker in any aspect. Even if you go only for skills/abilty I wouldn't buy it.