i first thought that randall may have been a little to slick for phillips, but phillips is a huge super light weight. i think he would catch randall and stop him in the later rounds. frankie was very technically sound but i think the size would matter as well. that match could still be made as we speak! for both are still fighting in their mid to late 40's.
Ive got to go with Frankie aswell...I think late in the fight will be very tense for him though as Vince's size, workrate and power start taking their toll.
Having seen Frankie take some absolute bombs from the likes of Rosario and Pendleton as a youngster, I've got to bank on him to take Vince's right hand and outbox him to to a close, but clear points win. 8-4, possibly 7-5 with perhaps a knockdown to Vinny's credit.