From 140 up PBF is way overrated alltime ??

hes the best fighter since roy jones anyway.

 

i mean....

he would slay margarito
easily beat cintron, quintana, clottey
probably beat pw..
(if quintana could do it... floyd would have no prob... but pw does cause some match up problems)
most difficult fight would be cotto...

so 4/5 @ worse
and could easily & convincingly go 5/5

how is he over rated?

 

PBF's resume past 135 is slightly overrated IMO

 

The thread starter is massive troll who comes into ESB under a diffrent alias every month and hates on the same fighters, he has gone by usernames cangriman,ganchozurdo and a couple of others I can't remember right now but he is of no use he makes the same exact thread subjects each time too, I just dont get why ESB does'nt put a ban on his IP address.

 

STFU nobody is picking him head to head against the majority of those guys.

You are just trying to instigate ****.

 

what is ur point? u r talking head to head...who he beat is not as important as his skill set....say what u want about his fights...he DESTROYED Gatti, beat judah EASY and beat a huge ODH and ko'd hatton and he ruled the world at 130-135....to say he cant beat any of those guys or has no chance besides hagler (obviously) makes no sense...he has as much skill as any of them

 

Yeah I am getting sick of this stupid ****. We are getting more and more of these threads that are along the lines of "people are claiming Pacman could beat RJJ, is pacman overrated" and making other rediculous claims about what nuthuggers have supposedly said when in fact no one here ever did say such things and they are making it up to instigate childish name calling threads.

 

I am definitely picking him head to head over ODH and Tito...the rest would be competitive besides hagler...hearns is a bit big too...great fighters bring out the best in PBF

 

There's no logic here at all. You can't speculate he'd win EASY and then rate him on that.

 

i agree but is he overrated cause he didnt prove it

 

Judah ODH and hatton are good wins...I dont think it is overrated...they are solid wins...I dont think anyone is saying he has a hopkins resume going

 

but he can do it...u agree so he is NOT overrated...he is ****ing frustrating!!!!!! he would SLAY margarito...****..come back floyd and shut up the haters

 

how about the logic of opinion...and watching him never lose a fight?

 

atsch Floyd doesn't move or fight like he used to. Except you think Floyd who fought @ 130 is the same guy who fought @ 146...