G.o.a.t. ®

Well he should be on the list then no?

 

there is no GOAT...just greats in different eras

 

You should have Greb and Pep on that list.

The two Leonards (SR and Benny) should be on that list. Monzon, Whittaker, Saddler all deserve consideration.

RJJ should be taken off the list. And so should Jofre.

 

I voted for Robinson, but considering only guys on this list we might be able to make a case for Duran.

As for whether or not PBF belongs on the list, that's laughable. He is not only not anywhere near GOAT, he isn't even the best ever in any division he has fought in.

Boo

 

Sugar Ray Robinson

 

1. Henry Armstrong
2. Sugar Ray Robinson
3. Harry Greb


The rest aren't even close

 

Robinson is the greatest in my opinion

Names like greb, langford, charles, walker, tunney and pep rate higher in my book than jofre, jones and louis in my opinion but each to there own and to be fair jones is possible the most talented fighter ever

 

Mayweather isn't even on the list?

 

G.o.a.t. on the list is Ali. The only guy on the list with a chance to beat Ali would be Louis. The other guys are just too small and he would work them over. Even if this was a P4P list, I still put him @ the top: Two distinct careers, 3 years in exile, KOing two unbeatable fighters, coming out on top of the most competitive era in the heavyweights when he was physically well beyond his prime.