Tunney handily. Patterson can’t outbox him & won’t knock him out, either. He’s giving up everything here sans handspeed & power. Tunney in a moderately competitive affair, maybe a 9-6, 9-5-1?
Love Floyd but I absolutely agree with you here, although I actually would remove the "moderately" adjective, I think Patterson especially the post-title Patterson would give a very good account of himself and would be quite capable of springing the upset.
“Can’t” why can’t he? Patterson had a style and tools that Gene never seen before in his life. Gene fought short slow white men who kept their hands by their waist. These men didn’t know how to move their upper body, or throw punches in combinations outside of a retired gassed Dempsey Floyd was innovative in bringing a very dangerous high guard peek a boo style into boxing. Floyd threw combinations with speed that was unmatched, Floyd threw triple jab combinations, Floyd mixed up the head and body with combinations, Floyd moved his head and upper body bobbing and weaving with grace… Tunney’s opponents on film looked like vacationing street car conductors compare to Floyd.
Patterson was faster, hit harder and beat better heavyweights. Plus, he had a left hook reminiscent of a guy who KO'd Tunney. And he was black, which scared Tunney to his core.
Well that certainly counts for a lot in a fantasy setting where you’re discussing the fight as it would happen, doesn’t it? I wasn’t aware mythical match ups now began at the negotiating table.
None relevant to how a fight in a ring would play out. Issues that do affect ring performance get glossed over for other fighters day & night.