Both guys had a very similar style (shoulder roll and counter punching skills) and would have made for a classic chess match. Who wins this at MW?
I've only seen a little footage on Benton but Toney was much more accomplished so I would have certainly have to go with him… stylistic similarities withstanding...
I'm going with Toney, I believe he was accurate enough to land on Georgie Benton and take the majority of the rounds.
Don't underestimate Benton, the only reason why he never got a title shot was because he beat Joey Giardello.