Cooney was a hell of alot more impressive against Holmes than Go-Go was against Bowe. People forget that even with the point deductions, Cooney was ahead on all three scorecards.
Yes Bowe was fading no doubt, it was evident in the third Holyfield fight and few before also. I don't think Cooney hit harder than Bowe, with the left hook probably, but Bowe had a better right and combinations. Golota was able to show nice defensive skills against Bowe- lateral and head movement, slipping, rolling, countering... And it would take far less combos to finish Cooney
No, actually you are right and my memory was off. Holmes was ahead 113-111 113-111 115-109. Cooney had 3 points deducted for low blows, so Cooney would have been winning the fight without the deductions.
While Cooney would have been winning without deductions he shouldn't have been. It would have been extremely poor scoring.
I would go with Cooney early .. Golata is the all time front runner quitter to me .. I'd see Cooney land early and hard and Andrew would quit.