Like I said they aren't the greatest boxers nor highly skilled but they OBVIOUSLY had something or else they wouldn't have made it anywhere near the top. It's a common and stupid myth among you guys who **** on the older era that any ole' bar room fighter could have made it to the top and gave the champ problems.
This is an exaggeration. The less skilled men who made it to the top in certain past eras were tougher, more rugged, and more relentless than "any ole' bar room fighter." Some were blessed with great punching power too. These attributes, combined with some basic training and rudimentary technique, can go a long way, especially against opponents who aren't physically imposing or adept at using techniques that can thwart brawn and aggression.
Schmeling is a very interesting fighter, from a technical standpoint. He fought from an orthodox stance, but he basically turned the boxing book upside down. His opponent would lead with a jab, and he would lead with his right hand, and use it to counter the jab. If you didnt leave yourself open, he simply pushed your left aside and countered you. He would then move in with left hooks to the body, and often close the deal with uppercuts. He was almost a chimera, in that the right side of his body was a technical boxer, and the left side was a pressure fighter. He was the kind of opponent that nobody would relish fighting if they knew what they were dealing with.
Yeah, he had a great record against the cream of the crop of his day, such as it was. Took too many punches and plodded a bit much to be considered one of the best pure boxers of all time though or to merit comparisons to Mayweather. And In This Corner quotes Mickey Walker as saying that "of course Sharkey was a better boxer" than Schmeling.
This of course has nothing to do with either of the following: 1. Walkers career best performance was holding Sharkey to a draw, while Schmeling annihilated him. 2. Walker was trained in the American tradition, which differed significantly from the European tradition.
Schmeling always respected Walker for the fight that he put up. After he beat Joe Louis, he attended one of his fights. He walked past all the former heavyweight champions lined up in their chairs, straight up to Walker , and shook his hand.